Showing posts with label defamation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label defamation. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 17, 2017

Psst, Mary, the truth is in the numbers UPDATED 10/18/17

During the President's Report at last night's school board meeting, Mary Birks was raving about Jan Klein, Director of Business. You may remember how I listed three reports from Right To Knows, where the FY ending in August 2017, were changed in three consecutive reports.


Members of the community, as well as a board member have called for an outside audit. At 18:10 time stamp October 17, 2017 school board meeting video, Mary Birks quotes John Irving. 
“Don't forget this, too: Rumors aren't interested in the unsensational story; rumors don't care what's true.”
But at 24:19 of the October 17, 2017 school board meeting video, Mary reported,
Harassment and defamation of character have no place with our professional staff and will not go unanswered.
Here's the thing, Mary. It isn't harassment and defamation of character if the financials are constantly changing. There is also the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. You said it yourself that there were over 40 Right To Knows filed since September. Do you know why so many RTKs were filed? Watch yourself in action at the 40:22 time stamp. A resident asked questions and you were not going to do a back and forth with him.

Birks didn't stop there. Watch how she deals with the same resident mentioned above at the 56:26 time stamp. We were told that Jo Posti was going to make a presentation on the Capital Campaign "reset." Nick asked if we were going to see the presentation. All Birks said was, "Nope." What a nasty woman! 

Mary, the last commenter was absolutely correct. At 1:02:25, we have the right to express our opinions and we are very upset with how we, the public, are being treated at these meetings. 

So before you send your lawyers here to shut me down, let me just say that you are doing nothing to garner votes. Your attitude sucks. Having a Candidates Forum with just your slate present is despicable. How you preside at a meeting is unbelievable. Remember, Karma is a bitch.

Update October 18, 2017 9:02 AM Watch School Board Director Hugh Beal's reaction after Mary Birks shut down Mt. Lebanon resident, Nick Meduho. Also, please read what Mike Riemer, Stephen Strotmeyer, and Aviva Diamond say about community participation.
US Supreme Court Chief Justice Earl Warren said: “education is perhaps the most important function of state and local governments.” Pennsylvania’s system of more than 500 locally-elected school boards epitomizes participatory government. In Mt. Lebanon, our residents elect the board of school directors empowered to decide on educational and financial matters with community needs, values, and expectations in mind. Community participation in that decision-making process should be encouraged. School directors are reflective of our constituency, and the ability to engage in open discussion with residents is critical to effective, accountable, transparent and ethical public school governance. Our residents should be made to feel welcome at all public meetings, whether as observers or participants. Future encouragement of residents to express personal viewpoints, whether in agreement or opposition to the school board needs to be cultivated and facilitated.
Ultimately, as voters, you have the opportunity to indicate your support for candidates that value a variety of views within Mt. Lebanon.
This November 7th, if you value representative democracy at the most grassroots level, please vote for Mike Riemer (in both the 4-year & 2-year seats), Stephen Strotmeyer, and Aviva Diamond. Our slate will work to restore a willingness to engage in civil discussions with our community as they pertain to our educational framework.

Thursday, October 17, 2013

Mt. Lebanon Magazine sued UPDATED 2X

Photo at DUI checkpoint brings suit against Mt. Lebanon Magazine

A Washington County man sued the managing editor of Mt. Lebanon Magazine along with a photographer whose work appeared in the magazine, claiming defamation.

John W. Pinto of Cecil filed an arbitration claim Thursday in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court against managing editor Merle Jantz and photographer George Mendel. Pinto is seeking $35,000.

According to the court filing, Pinto claims the defendants published a photograph of him standing near a police officer at an apparent drunken driving checkpoint in 2012. His face was blurred in the photo.

He said the magazine wrote that his Volvo was the first vehicle to enter a DUI checkpoint on Washington Road and talked about field sobriety tests.

Pinto said the magazine falsely conveyed to readers that he was arrested for drunken driving. Pinto was not arrested, according to the lawsuit.

Magazine editor-in-chief Susan Fleming Morgans referred comment to Mt. Lebanon's solicitor.

Update October 18, 2013 12:11 AM Man sues Mt. Lebanon Magazine for defamation

Update October 19, 2013 5:33 PM Article is on page 36-37 here in the September 2012 issue of mtl Magazine.