Showing posts with label toxicologist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label toxicologist. Show all posts

Sunday, November 23, 2014

"This project continues to move forward."

That is what Kristen Linfante says about the toxic turf project. In addition to "robbing Peter to pay Paul," the commissioners continue to ignore warnings from doctors. The latest report comes out of Amarillo, TX. Pediatric oncologists are noticing a trend.
Artificial turf may be linked to cancer
AMARILLO, TEXAS -- Artificial turf--it's used everywhere. Football fields, soccer stadiums, playgrounds, they all have it-- but many times we don't give this fake grass, or what's in it, too much thought.
"If it wasn't safe they wouldn't have us playing on it, so I guess I trust my school and my principals and my coaches", said Palo Duro High school student, Malik Allen, who plays soccer and football.
Recently though, some have begun questioning its safety. After Amy Griffin, a soccer coach in Washington state compiled a list of around 30 soccer players who have developed rare types of blood cancer, national attention is now on the issue. Griffin says around 22 of those diagnosed, are goalies. She says they're the players who spend the most time diving onto the turf.
Doctors here in Amarillo say they are noticing a trend as well.
"Over the last three decades the cancer rate in children is increasing and it's quite a bit, it's concerning," said Dr. Turner, a pediatric oncologist at Texas Tech.
But Dr. Turner also says we don't know why this is happening. He says most types of blood cancer are linked to genetics, or certain viruses like epstein bar, but that environmental factors could be contributing as well.
"Benzene," he said, has been shown to cause cancer."
Benzene and Butadiene are both volatile organic compounds, or VOC's, and are used in the production of rubber tires. In large enough quantities, they have been linked to various types of leukemia.
It's not the actual artificial turf grass itself that some think is dangerous, but what they use to fill in the grass to make it softer when athletes fall. It's called "crumb rubber", and it's not just found in stadiums, but also children's playgrounds, like Medi-Park in Amarillo.
But, adds Dr. Turner, "it's hard to tell an association vs. being causal."
The EPA has yet to do a rigorous study on this link and refuses to comment to any news outlets, but studies conducted by the California government showed trace amounts of Benzene and Butadiene in the crumb rubber used in artificial turf.
"I think it'd be money well spent to do the studies to look for any possible association with these products and leukemias and lymphomas," said Dr. Turner.
A study done by the California department of resources and recycling says there is added danger for exposure to Benzene when the crumb rubber is exposed to heat, but that it has not been studied thoroughly enough yet.
A year ago, almost to the day, the commissioners told residents that their preference was organic infill. See Son of a bitch Just like everything else related to this project, that was a lie. Franklin on organic infill.

My message to the Commission back in February compared the turf project to the tobacco industry. They're required to have warning statements on their ads and products.

I had shared this interview of one of our nation's foremost experts on synthetic turf here on Lebo Citizens. David S Brown, Sc.D. is a public health toxicologist. Artificial Turf Fields: A Troubling Perspective 

Two local pediatric groups wrote about toxic turf.
Local pediatric blog writes about tire crumb infill UPDATED

The EPA said that more studies are needed. Have they done any more? NO.

Tomorrow, the commissioners will be discussing the toxic turf project during the Commission Discussion Session. They will be confirming Feller's inappropriate approval of change order number 1 and moving money out of one project to pay for this one, which was "only" to be costing taxpayers $750,000.

With all this said, "This project continues to move forward."
                                                       - Kristen Linfante
                                                         Fri, Nov 21, 2014 5:39 pm


Sunday, October 19, 2014

"We were days away from the infill process....We said regardless, stop everything."



Coach Griffin has heard from toxicologists all over the country, telling her that she is not wrong. Local governments are stopping the process and aren't willing to take the chance. But Dave Brumfield, Kristen Linfante, Steve Silverman, and John Bendel are willing to take the chance on yours and their kids.


Thursday, June 12, 2014

"Field Enhancements" Project meeting recap UPDATED 3X

I have been saving some photos, waiting for the right time to share them on Lebo Citizens. I think it is the right time.

Tonight, Dan Deiseroth talked about flooding on Cedar Blvd. He said that Dixon floods, but never Middle and Wildcat Fields. Evidently, those fields have higher elevations and are not in the FEMA designated floodplain.

Here are some pics of the Wildcat Parking Lot flooding on May 28, 2014.
Wildcat Parking Lot flooding 05.28.14

Wildcat Parking Lot flooding 05.28.14

Wildcat Parking Lot flooding 05.28.14

Wildcat Parking Lot flooding 05.28.14

Wildcat Parking Lot flooding 05.28.14

The following photos illustrate the higher elevations as explained tonight at the "Field Enhancements" meeting. The bids show that fields are at "grade (street) level." The fields are far below Cedar Blvd, and obviously below the pool.










There was mention of an Add Alternate for a storm water filtration system. Here is what I was able to get from the bids.




Dan, feel free to use any of these photos in your next presentation. I am glad that the one you showed tonight was helpful for your business. I know who reads my blog because they recognized the photo immediately. Thanks for reading, Folks!

What I learned tonight is that Andy McNitt is not a toxicologist. The ESB was not given the plans, as David Donnellan claimed. I need to listen to the podcast because I think he mentioned other boards, as well. I learned that fresh strawberries are dangerous. And that artificial turf is perfectly safe, since there are poisons all around us.

Readers, feel free to share your thoughts about tonight's "Field Enhancements" meeting. I found out that our PIO coined that phrase since "artificial turf" has a negative connotation. Yes, I certainly feel better about it.

The podcast has been uploaded on to lebocitizens.com It is also available here.



Update June 13, 2014 2:35 PM Here is what Google Earth says about the elevations of Dixon, Middle, and Wildcat Fields.

Update June 14, 2014 2:40 PM I received Addendum #2 from Gateway Engineers on Thursday, June 12, 2014 at 4:10 PM. It includes:

 4.2. Per grading plan there is fill installation required to raise the southwest corner to elevation.

Specification changes include:














Update June 15, 2014 7:10 PM Here is the information I promised from the RTK concerning pitching mounds on Middle and Wildcat Fields.

No time for two local experts to weigh in on artificial turf

From: John Bendel <jbendel@mtlebanon.org>
Date: June 12, 2014 7:56:41 AM EDT
To: Charlotte Stephenson 
Cc: Stephen Feller <sfeller@mtlebanon.org>, Commission <commission@mtlebanon.org>
Subject: Re: Thursday evening forum - Toxicologist

Charlotte,

At this point, less than 12 hours from the field meeting, I do not feel there is enough time for the municipality to contact and prepare for a new speaker that you may refer for tonight's meeting. I appreciate your willingness to search for someone and I encourage you to refer names to Steve Feller. I have shared my views with the Commission and a recommendation that we bring someone in to the next Commission discussion session.

Thank you for your input and work on this.
_______________________________
Dear John,

I am disheartened that you are unwilling to permit me the entire short window that I already was given to produce a credentialed and expert opinion on this issue. The audience that most likely will attend tonight's forum is the very audience that needs to hear credible feedback about this plan. Inviting an expert of caliber to a Commission meeting will have much less importance than what is necessary at tonight's forum. I made tremendous headway in a short period of time.

The Commission asked municipal staff, who have no scientific or public health background to my knowledge, to find an appropriate resource. As I understand it, Susan is a PIO, Laura works with her and Steve is our municipal manager. While they have honed their skills working in their capacities, they were not logical choices to research a speaker on this health and safety issue. Further, I don't believe that any of the Commissioners work in the public health arena as well. 

John, I realize that service on the Commission is a time consuming effort and most of you are juggling day jobs. That, however, is absolutely no excuse for not serving the health and safety concerns of this community to the best of one's ability. This is one of the most important responsibilities that you are your associates have been given! The reality is that you passed this important matter off to staff unfairly given the late notice and their limited knowledge base so of course, no positive results were achieved.

That being said, since I left the Commission Chamber on Tuesday evening at 11:00 PM, I have obtained an opinion from Dr. Bernard Goldstein. He is a former Dean of the University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health, an environmental toxicologist whose research interests have focused largely on the concept of biological markers in the field of risk assessment. He has published in the areas of blood toxicity, the formation of cancer-causing substances (free radicals) following exposure to inhalants and global issues in environmental medicine. He is a previous chair of the department of environmental and community medicine at the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson Medical School where he established the Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences Institute in addition to his service as an officer with the U.S. Public Health Service and as an administrator for research and development at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. His medical degree is from New York University. In his response to my inquiry late this morning, he wrote and I boldfaced the key points....

"Dear Ms Stephenson

Sorry not to have been responsive but am at a meeting related to the Gulf Oil spill and won't be back until next week...As I understand it, the concern is  whether any of the components are able to leach out of the artificial turf or be torn up in small enough particles to be inhaled or eaten by a child.  I was involved in a study of an artificial turf at Giants Stadium, but the concern ended up being due to something that had been inappropriately sprayed on to the turf rather than the turf itself which was judged to be harmless - and the turf we studied in the 1990s may well be  different from the one being used in Mt Lebanon

So the question I would ask is whether studies have been done determining if any chemical constituents would  be expected to leach out under usual outdoor conditions.   I don't think this is likely, but it needs to be testedIf the turf would break up into small pieces that could be swallowed by a small child, then a legitimate question is whether any toxic chemicals might leach out and be absorbed in the acid pH of the child's stomach."


Additionally, in less than 24 hours I have connected with Dr. James Fabisiak, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Environmental & Occupational Health
University of Pittsburgh Graduate School of Public Health

He wrote the following late this morning:

"Dear Ms. Stephenson,

I've seen your correspondence here with Dr. Goldstein regarding artificial turf.  Attached I have provided a very brief synopsis of what I know about artificial turf which you may find helpful.  It presents 3 research articles and 1 review article on the subject.  I provided the reference, link to full text when available, abstract (with highlights I added) and my interpretation.  It is clear that since artificial turf is rubber-derived in large part it will contain certain amounts of some chemicals with hazardous potential.  Most notably organic hydrocarbons of great variety and metals.  However, it appears that consensus is that overall systemic exposure to most to these will be very low and probably of little concern.  Much is this is derived by looking at dissolution in various biological fluids like sweat or gastric juice  which adds to strength to the conclusions and helps address Dr. Goldstein's point about stomach pH etc..    The one exception seems to be Lead which of course has toxic potential, especially in young children.  Turf material seem to vary widely in lead content and also may reflect the use of paints or pigments in addition to the rubber itself.  Modern products may be available that are certified to be low-lead or lead-free and maybe one can insist that these be used in your playground.  Now you mentioned that you yourself suffer from asthma (as does my son).  It is important that realize that much less work has been done in regarding the respiratory effects in these sensitive groups, so I think it prudent to at least acknowledge that potential risks in these individuals contains a little more uncertainty....I hope you find this helpful.  It is far from comprehensive, but I only learned to your concerns a few hours ago.  I'm sorry I cannot attend your meeting this evening (I have other plans and the notice is short)..."

I telephoned Dr. Fabisiak to clarify some points just a little while ago. He recommended sampling the product you are purchasing and having it evaluated in a laboratory for the chemical content, particularly the lead content. He mentioned having read some information last week about increased ACL injuries on artificial turf surfaces and that the products vary from supplier to supplier.

In summary, in the unfairly dictated short window of time you gave me, you now have on record two local and qualified experts who recommend laboratory testing evaluation of the product you are purchasing for our children. You simply cannot afford to ignore this recommendation. Please inform me as to your action plan so I understand that you are performing your duties responsibly.

Thank You,

Charlotte Stephenson

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

No toxicologist at Field "Enhancements" forum UPDATED

I asked the commissioners if they were able to get a toxicologist to speak at Thursday's Turf, I mean Field Enhancements educational forum and the answer was No. John Bendel and Kelly Fraasch got into it about that. Kelly said that the whole purpose of the meeting was to have a toxicologist speak about the safety of artificial turf. It turns out that they contacted someone as late as yesterday and he was unable to attend. Charlotte Stephenson spoke later and offered to bring a toxicologist. John wanted to vet the expert before permitting him to speak. Kristen piped up to say that they don't want anyone from Mt. Lebanon because they could be biased. You see, a Mt. Lebanon toxicologist could think the turf is perfectly safe, but is opposed to the cost. One resident thought that it was because there were no toxicologists who are in favor of artificial turf. John Bendel was getting snarky with me about the expert from Penn State, Dr. Andrew McNitt. What he failed to mention was that Andy has a partnership with FieldTurf, the artificial turf company whose VP of Global Marketing in Montreal was attacking me yesterday. I never heard back from Mr. Gill, by the way.

There is no conduit going in at Middle and Wildcat Fields, according to Bend it With Bendel. Funny, that is what is in the bid documents. There are no other phases, according to Bendel. John did send me this late this afternoon:

The commitments by the Sports Associations are as follows:

Soccer: $50,000
Baseball: $40,000
Lacrosse: $20,000 (lacrosse parents another $28,000 on their own and sent to the Endowment)
Softball: $7,500
Football: $6,500
Field Hockey: $1,000

The summary of contributions is attached. For some reason, I can read it with no problems on my iPad, but on my Mac laptop, it is junked up. Just a heads up. The title of the document is:

Non-municipal sources Initial Project Cost
 98% Committed

The bottom line totals, in case you can't read it, are 
Cash $101,879
Pledged $143, 250
Total $245,129

Here is the email that I never received. John sent it to me after the meeting, with an apology.

Sorry, I don't know what happened. I thought it went through

Sent from my iPhone

Begin forwarded message:
Elaine,

Yes, the June 12 meeting will be video recorded.

The Commission established that the non municipal funds be in hand before we award the contract, not when we accept the bids. The emails from David Donnellan and me confirm that. As far as the $5,000 from a corporate donor that will be available in December, the Commission will need to decide if we are willing to make an exception to the cash in hand requirement for a firm commitment for a relatively small amount.

The contributions made to the Endowment were primarily made by individuals. I do not believe the Endowment would release the names of contributors nor do I think they should. Moreover, I don't know why it matters who the individuals are that donated to the project. 

I am aware of the concern regarding surface temperatures on turf. Our speaker, Andy McNitt, will address this issue at the June 12 meeting.


On Jun 8, 2014, at 8:11 AM, "'egillen476@aol.com' via Commission" <commission@mtlebanon.org> wrote:
John,
Will the Mellon presentation be video recorded? If not, will there be an audio recording?



Please explain why the words "artificial turf" are never used in any of the LeboALERTS, or any other municipal announcements such as what is on the municipal website.



I would also like to confirm with you that the non-municipal funds (cash in hand) will be released to the municipality prior to the bid being accepted. Here is the email exchange. that you had with Dave Franklin and David Donnellan clarifying Dave Franklin's statement.Also, the $5000 being donated in December should not be considered as cash in hand. 


At the SAB meeting last week, Pam Scott asked about contributions made to the turf project. Dave Franklin asked Pam to specify which contributions by asking "Private?" She said yes. Who are the corporate sponsors and /or public donors and how much are their contributions?

During the SAB meeting, Kimberly Schevtchuk was on the defensive before she could even speak. She tried to share her research with the SAB but was fired questions from all angles. Many were the same questions that were asked of her previously. One of the issues that came up at the SAB meeting was turf temperatures. A Lebo Citizens reader shared his findings on my Lebo Citizens blog. I hope you consider reading this post.


Elaine Gillen
Note: I asked for corporate sponsors and public donors.

Shortly after I received John's email, Kristen sent me a confirmation that the meeting will be video recorded.

Well, that's all she wrote tonight. Good night.

Update June 11, 2014 1:09 AM I lied. I'm still up. A WTAE camera person (gender neutral, thank you) was filming residents during Citizen Comments. I wish I had taken a picture of the commissioners. They were white as ghosts. They had no idea what was going on. Are they doing a story on the Newcomers' Tax or are they going to write about how the community is getting screwed over the MWC turf project? We will know for sure in July. :)

Update June 11, 2014 4:30 PM Independent expert?

Andrew McNitt's Overview

Current
Past
Education
Connections
500+ connections
Websites

Andrew McNitt's Experience

Professor of Soil Science/Turfgrass

Penn State University

Educational Institution; 10,001+ employees; Higher Education industry
2012 – Present (2 years)

Associate Professor of Soil Science/Turfgrass

Penn State University

Educational Institution; 10,001+ employees; Higher Education industry
2006 – 2012 (6 years)

Andrew McNitt's Projects

Andrew McNitt's Skills & Expertise

  1. Agronomy
  2. Horticulture
  3. Soil
  4. Turf
  5. Golf Courses

Andrew McNitt's Education

Penn State University

Ph.D.Soil Science

1995 – 2000

Penn State University

M.S.Agronomy

1991 – 1993

Penn State University

B.S.Horticulture

1979 – 1983

Penns Valley High School

Andrew McNitt's Additional Information

Websites:
Interests:
Athletic Field Construction and Management, Sports Fields, Synthetic Turf,
Groups and Associations:
STMA, KAFMO, Pennsylvania Turfgrass Council, PSU Turfgrass Alumni
Update June 11, 2014 7:07 PM At last night's meeting, Charlotte Stephenson offered to locate a toxicologist for tomorrow night's meeting. Here is the email exchange she had with the commissioners and manager today. It is a little confusing to follow, but start from the bottom of the Google Doc. 
Note: Steve Feller contacted Dr. Johnson on Monday afternoon!

Monday, June 2, 2014

Bend it with Bendel

According to the press release issued by PIO Susan Morgans, Commission Vice President and Sports Advisory Board member John Bendel will be facilitating the $11,000 Infomercial at Mellon Auditorium on June 12.

The purpose of this meeting is to update Mt. Lebanon residents about the Middle/Wildcat "Field Improvements" a.k.a. Artificial Turf Project with an unbiased toxicologist and the unbiased Director of the Center for Sports Surface Research at Penn State, Andrew McNitt. It was revealed that Penn State and FieldTurf, an artificial turf company, formed a partnership in July 2009. The cost of this public outreach will be $11,000, according to Municipal Engineer Dan Deiseroth, from Gateway Engineering. You may recall that Gateway made the first contribution of $4,000 to the non-municipal portion of the the project. In the press release, there was no mention of a toxicologist or Penn State. Susan Morgans writes:
Commission Vice President John Bendel will facilitate the meeting, at which he and several consultants will speak and provide audio-visual presentations. 
"Bend it with Bendel" has never seen any documentation that states that artificial turf is unsafe. That translates to "Artificial Turf - proven to be safe!" It must be true. At least that is what the pro-turf signs indicate.

In the same Almanac article
Commissioner Kelly Fraasch then proposed that all Turf Task Force meetings be open to the public. She said other municipal task forces, such as the one handling a possible pay-as-you-throw trash program, were open for any member of the public to attend. Yet, some residents said they had been turned away from task force meetings related to the turf project.

In response, commissioner Dave Brumfield seemed to waver. He said he would like to hear from commissioner John Bendel, who was absent from the meeting, before offering a final opinion.

“I don’t have a problem with those meetings being public,” Brumfield said, “but they are not required to be public. I would want to hear what John has to say.”
We never did hear what John Bendel had to say. We didn't because I didn't ask him during Citizen Comments. The only way we got the SAB Financial Report at the last meeting is because I asked him point blank at the commission meeting. And if I don't ask, they don't tell. Brumfield didn't ask (of course!) and Kelly Fraasch never followed up.

"Bend it with Bendel" told us that the non-municipal funds were due May 15. Now, they are due before the commission awards the contract. Bid opening is June 17. I would guess that the contract would be awarded at the June 23 Commission meeting. That bought the SAB more than a month's time to raise the $250,000.

Another statement the PA governor hopeful made is that there is no Phase 2 to the project. However, on page 64 and 65 of the 2014 Manager's Recommended Budget 
23 Athletic Field Improvements. Installation of artificial turf and lights at Wildcat and Middle Fields $1,050,000.
Bendel, the one who has never heard anything bad about artificial turf, will end the June 12 Informercial, by addressing questions "suggested by the audience." That means there will be no Q & A. Future Gov. Bendel will be in control of the entire dog and pony show. My suggestion at the last commission meeting was to cancel this $11,000 Informercial and use the money toward fixing some roads.