Friday, February 1, 2013

Aerial survey coming this month

People have been asking me to blog about the deer survey that was passed on Monday night, but I have been hesitating since it is like waving a red flag in front of a bull.  Anytime I have brought up deer management, my commissioner would go into attack mode.

A group of us have been meeting with Commissioner Fraasch to find common ground concerning deer management.  Through many meetings, Kelly Fraasch was able to come up with an excellent plan for deer management, as well as a cost effective, yet quite accurate method to count deer in Mt. Lebanon. In her blog posting, Deer...Follow up! , Kelly writes:

The aerial survey has far less potential for human error. Pictures are taken from an airplane and a wildlife specialist is able to count our deer population, note where the herds are located and even tell us the gender of the deer.
Here’s more information about the aerial survey FLIR_surveys
wildlife professional
. A recent estimated cost by Susan Bernatas suggests it will cost about $5,400 per survey which would come in less than our budgeted cost.
In the Post Gazette article, it was noted that Kristen Linfante is still pushing for a cull while others are striving for a safer alternative to manage the deer population.
Deer survey coming next month

A survey to estimate the number of deer in the community will be taken next month.

Commissioners voted Monday to authorize municipal officials to solicit proposals for a survey to be conducted in February.

A late addition to the 2013 budget expenditures allots $12,000 for surveys as part of the effort to mitigate safety hazards caused by deer.

Commissioners planned to authorize two such counts this year, with the second one targeted for November, but they revised their intentions prior to Monday's vote.

A second survey would take place in February 2014, if deemed necessary. More accurate comparisons can be drawn from counts done at the same time of year as opposed to different seasons.

The municipality last conducted a deer survey in 2007.

Commissioner Kristen Linfante questioned the need for a repeat survey next year, saying a formula is available to estimate future deer populations based on an initial count. She said that according to her conversations with the head of a research company that does surveys, conducting two in consecutive months might result in a more accurate count.

The municipality plans to install additional signs and conduct a public education campaign in an attempt to decrease the number of deer-related accidents.

While many residents agree on the need for action to improve safety, the method of how to do it has caused divisiveness. Some argue that a cull using high-powered rifles would be the most effective method; others oppose measures that involve firearms.

Kimberly Schevtchuk said she supports a proposal by Commissioner Kelly Fraasch that involves deer sterilization. Such a method has "proved effective in other communities. It keeps public safety a priority," Ms. Schevtchuk said.

Ms. Linfante, however, expressed concern about the short-term results of a sterilization program and said she would support it in conjunction with a cull.

Read more: http://www.post-gazette.com/stories/local/neighborhoods-south/the-south-at-a-glance-672829/#ixzz2JZz5XSzF

Meanwhile on Facebook, mtl Magazine posted a photo of foxes that are in our community.

Photo: From right here in town. So cool!
Photo by mtl - Mt. Lebanon Magazine


 I want to thank Kelly for working with us. By listening to any commission podcast regarding deer management, it is easy to pick out our committee. It consisted of every single person whom my commissioner attacked.  Through listening, collaborating, and communicating, Commissioner Fraasch was able to move the deer management program forward.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

Isn't it interesting that Kelly seems to always come up with an alternative that saves her constituents money.
She listens, she investigates, she works and finds a solution. Nice job Kelly, thank you!

Anonymous said...

I haven't seen a deer on my street for 2-3 months. I have never seen a fox.

One thing we can all do to prevent deer/auto accidents is slow down.

Does anybody drive the speed limit in this town? It sure doesn't seem like it. Some of the worse streets for speeding are also the busiest: Washington Road, Beadling, Lindendale, Kelso, Mt. Lebanon Blvd., Jefferson, Roycroft, Woodland, Bower Hill, North Meadowcroft, Scrubgrass, Cedar, Cochran, Beverly, Castle Shannon, North Meadowcroft, etc. Unfortunately, many of these streets have a lot of wooded areas, too.

While I commend Commissioner Fraasch for coming up with a more humane solution to controlling the deer population, I think it's sad that some people aren't interested in sharing this planet with these sweet creatures.

Anonymous said...

Shot them!

Lebo Citizens said...

You did? And people get nervous when I use the word "execute." When my commissioner filed a report against me, the name Gabby Giffords came up.
Oh wait, didn't I see your name in the eblast about gun control?
Elaine

Anonymous said...

Why isn't "your commissioner" jumping all over this ? She amended the budget to include a deer survey. Her last blog posting is about killing deer following the Newtown shooting. http://valuemtlebanon.com/content/interesting-article-about-deer

Anonymous said...

To 8:04 AM

How proud you must be! UGH!
It's truly pathetic that some people get their highs by killing animals. Humans used to kill to survive; now they do it for sport.
Shame on you.

Anonymous said...

Another Mt. Lebanon survey!

I wonder if when the resiults come out, whatever they are, Ed Kubit will declare he talked to an equal number of deer that opposed the findings of the survey. LOL

Lebo Citizens said...

No, 1:12 PM, Kristen Linfante will be at the meeting saying that we forced the deer to sign it or be counted. Then she will blog about her mother taught her to never lie. Read about me on her Real Lebo blog. See http://www.reallebo.com/2010/04/my-mother-toaught-me-never-to-lie.html?m=0
Elaine

Anonymous said...

Good one, Elaine ! I remember that meeting. You were trying to speak and she was yelling at you from the audience. Ed Kubit did nothing to her but tried to silence you instead !

Anonymous said...

I just don't get Kristen.

Kelly basically shepherded through a way to control the deer population that is almost completely without controversy. Rather than use high powered rifles we snip the female deer tubes.

That seems to do two things:
1. Control the deer population
2. Not upset the people who are afraid of using high powered rifles next to our homes

I don't see why Kristen would not hop on board with both feet.

Anonymous said...

5:54 wonder why the self-appointed morality police didn't see any need to report one board member's misdeed - obviously disregarding the safety of our community's residents by speeding on streets in 2,500+ lb. vehicle. While on the other hand they felt morally outraged enough to ostracize another for considering others safety and opting to abandon their car and walk home!
These bullies and their holier-than-thou attitudes make me sick.

Lebo Citizens said...

I am sleeping a little better these days. I have been purging and repairing, little by little, in preparation for moving. Maybe Kristen isn't hopping because she is not getting rid of me yet.
The nightmares have started again UPDATED

I can't praise Kelly enough for all of her hard work and her compassion. Instead of Kristen saying, "I know how difficult this must be for you. I will insure that no culling will be next to your house or in any area which could endanger anyone," I got, "If it is living in your basement, then so be it. If it is moving, then so be it."
SO BE IT???
Gotta love her compassion. This is who will be our commission president next year, all because of a screw up in the alleged rotation. YIKES!

Again, Kelly, thank you, thank you, thank you! You rock!
Elaine

Anonymous said...

Speeding tickets are on public record, Elaine.

Lebo Citizens said...

I am aware of that, 6:04 PM. I cannot locate it. Please back up your statement either here or email it to me. Thanks.
Elaine

Anonymous said...

10:08 who are you talking about? Ifit's on public record there's no concern about mentioning their name.

Lebo Citizens said...

7:10 PM, I moved a couple of comments over into the spam folder until I get verification. Hang tight.
Elaine

Anonymous said...

Elaine,

Shouldn't the idea be to lessen the deer population by using the following criteria:

1. In a manner that is SAFE
2. In a manner that is cost effective
3. In a manner that is respectful of the animals

I put those in order of importance. The number one goal should be the safety of our residents. Given stories that have come out regarding the last rifle cull, I think it is about time the commission consider a safe alternative to having residents be terrified of high powered rifle bullets going off in the dark of night.

If Commissioner Fraasch can figure out, with the help of ALL other commissioners and staff, how to pull off a birth control cull (without drugs which makes the deer meat inedible and dangerous) then we absolutely ought to follow that path as long as it is not terribly more expensive than shooting the deer. If it more expensive then I think we should have a discussion about the merits of each method.

I am ok with controlling the deer population. But I want to do it humanely and cost-effectively, and efficiently.