Showing posts with label Right to Know. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Right to Know. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 27, 2018

It's not as complicated as it looks.

Don't let this scare you.


I made it all the way to the end of the flow chart, but it did cost $7000 for the PA Supreme Court to tell me that they wouldn't hear the Petition for Allowance of Appeal. We don't have the Right To Know where lethal weapons are being discharged on Mt. Lebanon private properties. 

Thursday, May 24, 2018

I knew it was wrong!

Oh the crap I have had to deal with in this community by public officials! To be told over and over to file a Right To Know for answers and then receive "anonymous" comments from school board members saying that I have wasted thousands of dollars on Right To Know Requests, is just part of it. The eblasts to encourage folks to vote for the other two finalists in the Best of the 'Burgh contest was really messed up. At least the honor of being a finalist couldn't be taken away from me. Remember how my poor husband was brought up? Despicable. A former commissioner joked about igniting me, and also claimed that I was going through her garbage at 6 AM, and then resigned because she was "dying." Being taken to court all because I had PTSD and wanted to know which areas to avoid when the deer killing was taking place. Uninvited visitors at my door. The police calls. The threats. All the BS from former school board presidents for EIGHT years. Don't forget all the cease and desists from the municipality And then there was this. Can you get away with this in your District? A federal court ruled yesterday that public officials, from President Trump down to Tim Steinhauer, cannot block people from following their Twitter accounts. I knew it was wrong!!!

Tim, I knew that what you were doing to me was wrong. Nobody would listen to me. Many have been harassed for years in this "community with character."

As late as Monday, a resident wants to file a class action suit against me. I was within my rights to go the PA Ethics Commission for a decision. If it had been a frivolous complaint, it would have been tossed out. But. It. Wasn't. I went through all the proper steps before, during, and after filing my complaint.

With all this and more, I am the one who is constantly being labeled as the one with the problem. I was raised to stand up for what I believed in. I raised my kids that way too. I am revisiting that philosophy, because this really sucks.

Monday, February 5, 2018

Mt. Lebanon Catch 22 UPDATED 02/07/18 @ 2:35 PM

Remember this post? Another step in the right direction. Well forget it. I think it may be easier to share the emails.

First email
From: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>
To: schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Thu, Jan 25, 2018 7:56 pm
Subject: Capital Campaign spreadsheet

School board directors,

Every month, my friend Nick Meduho would file a Right To Know for the two page Century of Excellence Capital Campaign spreadsheet. I would like to request the two pages for YTD 12/31/17 by emailing the Board, and moving forward, I am requesting that both pages are put on the Capital Campaign website instead of just the one page every month.

Thanks.

Elaine Gillen


Second request
From: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>
To: schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Thu, Feb 1, 2018 12:25 pm
Subject: two page report

Dear School Board Directors,

I had sent an email requesting the two page Capital Campaign report for YTD 12/31/17, as well as the complete report be posted on the capital campaign website moving forward. Mike Riemer was kind enough to let me know that moving forward, the entire Capital Campaign reports will be published.

I would still like to receive the two page Capital Campaign report for YTD 12/31/17. Is Mike the only one who is permitted to share this report with me, or since it has been approved, can any of you email me that?

Thanks.

Elaine Gillen



Third request
From: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>
To: schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Mon, Feb 5, 2018 5:31 pm
Subject: Page 2

School Board Directors,

This is what is on the Century of Excellence website. https://www.mtlsd.org/uploaded/District/Century_of_Excllence/Capital_Campaign_Summary_YTD_ending_12.31.2017.pdf This report has been available monthly as is.
One. Page.
In order to receive page 2, a Right To Know had to be filed.

I am asking, once again, for page 2. I understand that moving forward, the Capital Campaign Summary YTD ending 01.31.18 will include both pages, but I would like page 2 of what is presently on the website. I would have had this by now, had I filed a Right To Know. Once again, I have to wait a week or so until I hear from the school board president, because the policy mandates that only the president can answer me. This is ridiculous.

Elaine Gillen




Then from the board president
From: Michael Riemer <mriemer@mtlsd.net>
To: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>; schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Mon, Feb 5, 2018 5:40 pm
Subject: Re: Page 2

Ms. Gillen,

I am in receipt of your previous email and have been addressing this to get the full information before I respond to your request. Also I have been under the weather the last two weeks. We will be addressing your email in due time.

Mike Riemer
For the Board

My response
From: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>
To: mriemer <mriemer@mtlsd.net>; schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Mon, Feb 5, 2018 6:21 pm
Subject: Re: Page 2

Mike,

I am sorry to hear that you have been under the weather the last two weeks. I know that you were unable to attend the last school board meeting. A lot of nasty stuff has been going around. Couldn't Sarah have supplied the information that I have been requesting? On my blog, I have been criticized for wasting tax dollars by filing RTKs, but it does take the pressure off of the president. Perhaps that is why past presidents have told us to file RTKs. By filing a RTK, I would usually get an answer in five days or less. I'm not sure what "in due time" means. I am only asking for one page that shouldn't require any redactions. Wasn't the second page populated a month ago?

Elaine Gillen

Response from the board president
From: Michael Riemer <mriemer@mtlsd.net>
To: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>; schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Mon, Feb 5, 2018 8:21 pm
Subject: Re: Page 2


Ms. Gillen,

As per Mt. Lebanon School District Board Policy KDB, which is in alignment with Pennsylvanian right to know law we are required to log all public records requests. Please feel free to file a right to know on the subject matter at hand.

Thank you.

Mike Riemer
For the Board

SO I DID.

Update February 6, 2018 9:00 AM Mt. Lebanon School District Board Policy KDB is available for viewing here.
https://www.mtlsd.org/uploaded/District/School_Board/Policies/K-SchoolCommunityHomeRelations/KDB_Public_Records.pdf

Update February 6, 2018 10:30 I heard back from Jeanine, the Open Records Officer. Notice how the attorneys had to be cc'ed. Billable hours, my friends. Ridiculous. This was for the second page of a published document.

From: Jeanine Szalinski <jszalinski@mtlsd.net>
To: E.T. Gillen <egillen476@aol.com>
Cc: Thomas Peterson <TPeterson@tuckerlaw.com>; Voltz, Chris <cvoltz@tuckerlaw.com>; Dr. Timothy Steinhauer <TSteinhauer@mtlsd.net>; Michael Riemer <mriemer@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Tue, Feb 6, 2018 10:08 am
Subject: Right to Know Request



Dear Mrs. Gillen,

Thank you for writing to Mt. Lebanon School District with your request for information pursuant to the Pennsylvania Right to Know Law.

On February 6, 2018, we received your request seeking: Page 2 of The Capital Campaign Summary YTD 12/31/17 in pdf format.

Please find attached a response to your request and any responsive document.

Sincerely,

Jeanine Szalinski
Administrative Assistant to the Superintendent
Asst. Board Secretary/Open Records Officer
Mt. Lebanon School District
7 Horsman Drive
Pittsburgh PA  15228
412-344-2077



I had to jump through hoops for PAGE 2:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/17s_cNCEUdm-u19aIPBEl6IAX21SVqcfG/view?usp=sharing

Update February 7, 2018 2:35 PM For future reference, since the monthly reports disappear from viewing when the latest report is posted, here is the link to Page 1 for YTD 12.31.17. https://drive.google.com/file/d/114Hi9y_-d1fiYkTPr5WSDv1cW2iUXgO9/view?usp=sharing

Monday, January 29, 2018

Another step in the right direction.

From: Michael Riemer <mriemer@mtlsd.net>
To: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>
Cc: schoolboard <schoolboard@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Mon, Jan 29, 2018 5:02 pm
Subject: Re: Capital Campaign spreadsheet


Ms. Gillen,

I have spoken with Dr. Steinhauer concerning this matter and moving forward all pieces of the Capital Campaign financial documents will be posted to the website. 

Thank you, 

Mike Riemer 

For the Board 

On Thu, Jan 25, 2018 at 7:56 PM, 'egillen476@aol.com' via SchoolBoard <schoolboardemaillist@mtlsd.net> wrote:
School board directors,

Every month, my friend Nick Meduho would file a Right To Know for the two page Century of Excellence Capital Campaign spreadsheet. I would like to request the two pages for YTD 12/31/17 by emailing the Board, and moving forward, I am requesting that both pages are put on the Capital Campaign website instead of just the one page every month.

Thanks.

Elaine Gillen

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

"Sharpshooting" 2018

I watched enough of last night's commission meeting to know that I had to file a Right To know for the proposal and contract between White Buffalo and Mt. Lebanon.

Kelly Fraasch made a point to voice her opinion about the cost of this program. Not only is she against the "sharpshooting" program in general, she thought the cost of $771.10 per deer for up to 100 deer was outrageous. When the commissioners first came up with the idea that we had too many deer in Mt. Lebanon, the cost was estimated to be around $250 per deer.

The vote was 3 to 1 in favor of continuing the deer killing program. Dave Brumfield checked with Steve McLean and Craig Grella before he voted yes. Steve "Fiscally Responsible" McLean supported it. We're still waiting for Craig's decision to be published.

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

A Work in Progress

For the second time in a month, the Century of Excellence Presentation was promised, but was removed from the November 13, 2017 agenda. It appears that we have entered a new Quiet Phase.

On October 16, 2017, Nick Meduho had asked about the Jo Posti reset presentation. His questions were not answered, so Nick had fifteen open Right To Knows with the School District when he passed away. I had to refile them in my name, as I had explained in an earlier post. The RTKs, all related to the Century of Excellence Capital Campaign or the Mt. Lebanon Foundation for Education (MLFE) are starting to come in.

I'm not sure how to go about this, so these will be in no particular order. I will continue to update with RTKs as I receive them.
  1. MLFE 990's 2013-2015
  2. "On November 8, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking: the most recent detailed statement by the Mt. Lebanon school board directors of any/all devises, bequests, grants, endowments, gifts, and donations, held and possessed by such school district (Mt. Lebanon), the proceeds thereof, the investments which have been made therewith, the income arising there from, the expenses of administration, and the purposes to which the income arising there from have been applied., Such statement shall be audited as hereinafter provided for the auditing of school finances." Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait.
  3. A comprehensive financial report for the Mt. Lebanon Foundation for Education for the fiscal year ending on June 30, 2017.
  4. Copies of all invoices pertaining to the purchase of stadium blankets which are being sold to benefit the MLFE.
  5. Payroll records for Sloane Astorino from when she began employment in 2015 to present.
  6. An absolute complete/comprehensive and accurate income/expense report for the Century of Excellence Capital Campaign for dates January 1, 2012 thru October 15, 2017 which will include all the following; #1 All revenues itemized including but not limited to dates, amount and source of each transaction being as specific as possible, I understand that specific donor names must be redacted. #2 All expenditures itemized including but not limited to date, amount, payee and category of each transaction being as specific as possible. #3 All balance of money whether they be in a bank account, the Pittsburgh Foundation, etc. as of September 15, 2017. #4 All itemized transfers of money with specific dates and amounts transferred back to and from the school district general account for the capital campaign account.                    The District has located, with respect to the Capital Campaign Fund, documents setting forth “Revenue Accounts” and “Expenditure Accounts” for the 2012-2013 school year, the 2013-2014 school year, the 2014-2015 school year, the 2015-2016 school year, the 2016-2017 school year and the 2017-2018 school year as of November 3, 2017. In addition, the District had located a document entitled “Mt. Lebanon School District Fund 27 Capital Campaign.” These documents provide you with your requested information
  7. The agreement between the Capital Campaign and the Pittsburgh Foundation that was approved on November 17, 2014.
  8. "Any/all documents in the form of contracts, agreements, disclosure forms, terms, etc. that each donor was either made aware of, agreed to and/or signed either when they donated any money to the Century of Excellence Campaign or have pledged." Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait. 
  9. "On November 8, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking: The detailed statement for fiscal year 2012 by the Mt. Lebanon school board directors of any/all devises, bequests, grants, endowments, gifts, and donations, held and possessed by such school district (Mt. Lebanon), the proceeds thereof, the investments which have been made therewith, the income arising there from, the expenses of administration, and the purposes to which the income arising there from have been applied., Such statement shall be audited as hereinafter provided for the auditing of school finances." Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait. 
  10. "On November 8, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking: The detailed statement for fiscal year 2013 by the Mt. Lebanon school board directors of any/all devises, bequests, grants, endowments, gifts, and donations, held and possessed by such school district (Mt. Lebanon), the proceeds thereof, the investments which have been made therewith, the income arising there from, the expenses of administration, and the purposes to which the income arising there from have been applied., Such statement shall be audited as hereinafter provided for the auditing of school finances." Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait. 
  11. "On November 8, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking: The detailed statement for fiscal year 2014 by the Mt. Lebanon school board directors of any/all devises, bequests, grants, endowments, gifts, and donations, held and possessed by such school district (Mt. Lebanon), the proceeds thereof, the investments which have been made therewith, the income arising there from, the expenses of administration, and the purposes to which the income arising there from have been applied., Such statement shall be audited as hereinafter provided for the auditing of school finances." Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait. 
  12. "On November 8, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking: The detailed statement for fiscal year 2015 by the Mt. Lebanon school board directors of any/all devises, bequests, grants, endowments, gifts, and donations, held and possessed by such school district (Mt. Lebanon), the proceeds thereof, the investments which have been made therewith, the income arising there from, the expenses of administration, and the purposes to which the income arising there from have been applied., Such statement shall be audited as hereinafter provided for the auditing of school finances." Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait. 
  13. "On November 8, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking: An absolute complete/comprehensive and accurate income/expense report for the MLFE for dates January 1, 2014 thru October 15, 2017 which will include all the following: 1) All revenues itemized including but not limited to dates, amount and source of each transaction being as specific as possible. Donor names to be omitted. 2) All expenditures itemized including but not limited to date, amount, payee and category of each transaction being as specific as possible. 3) All balance of money as of October 15, 2017."  Another thirty days, on top of what Nick had to wait. 
  14. District treasurer's reports from June 2013-December 2013
  15. District treasurer's reports June 2013
    District treasurer's reports July 2013
    District treasurer's reports August 2013
    District treasurer's reports September 2013
    District treasurer's reports October 2013
    District treasurer's reports November 2013
    District treasurer's reports December 2013
  16. The last RTK was combined with Number 13.

Monday, November 6, 2017

So how does this work? UPDATED 11/7/17 at 7:52 PM

I filed a Right To Know for a list of all of my friend, Nick Meduho's outstanding RTKs. As many of you know, Mary Birks would not answer Nick's questions. He would be told to file a RTK or that they "would get back to him." Always respectful, Nick would quietly return to his seat and then go home and file RTKs. My RTK was granted today. Nick had filed the following requests.

Nick Meduho's Open Requests
On October 30, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking “a detailed list of all the outstanding records requested from the late Nick Meduho.” 
Please note that for the requests due on or before the date of your Request, the District informed Mr. Meduho that it required additional time to respond to these requests pursuant to Section 902 of the RTKL
So how does this work? Do I have to refile all of these? Or can I just pay for Nick's requests and get them when he would have received them, had he not passed away?

Thanks, Mary. You never did get back to Nick.

Updated November 7, 2017 8:40 AM From Mary D. Birks' public Facebook feed:






















A friend writes: Do bullies recognize themselves? I don't think they often do.

Update November 7, 2017 7:52 PM I ended up refiling 15 RTKs. The official word from MTLSD:

From: Jeanine Szalinski <jszalinski@mtlsd.net>
To: E.T. Gillen <egillen476@aol.com>
Cc: Thomas Peterson <TPeterson@tuckerlaw.com>; Voltz, Chris <cvoltz@tuckerlaw.com>; Dr. Timothy Steinhauer <TSteinhauer@mtlsd.net>
Sent: Tue, Nov 7, 2017 3:07 pm
Subject: Right to Know Requests

Dear Mrs. Gillen:
To ensure compliance with and preserve your rights under the RTKL, you are required to file your own RTKL Requests. 
Specifically, under Section 703 of the RTKL, written requests must set forth the name and the address of the individual to receive the District’s response.  Under Section 1101(a) of the RTKL, only the Requester has the right to appeal the denial of a request for records.  
Some of the specific responses are ready to be sent, so if you wish to submit them individually we will respond to those upon receipt. The rest of the responses will be provided as soon as they are completed.

Sincerely,

Jeanine Szalinski
Administrative Assistant to the Superintendent
Asst. Board Secretary/Open Records Officer
Mt. Lebanon School District
7 Horsman Drive
Pittsburgh PA  15228
412-344-2077

Wednesday, November 1, 2017

When I ask, it's redacted. UPDATED 5:11 PM

The school district has gone overboard by redacting and withholding public information in Right To Knows about the Century of Excellence Campaign. I filed a RTK for "Sloane Astorino's handout with the campaign financial summary from her November 2016 PowerPoint presentation." This is what I received No financial summary. Just a redacted presentation orginally archived without redactions by Nick Meduho here.

And so the emails which emphasize the glut of redactions to the Open Records Officer with copies to the school board begin. RTK emails abt Sloane campaign financial summary 

This isn't the only instance where the school district has gone redaction crazy. From my post, The Butcher, The Baker, The Candlestick Makermy dear friend Nick M. had filed a RTK for the names of the Advisory Panel. They charged him for the redaction too, even though Lebomag had no problem listing a minor's name in their misinformation/propaganda. Under the Sunshine Law, the school district has the right to charge 25¢ per page of redactions.

Misinformation from 710 Washington Road
“Last year, the district launched the Century of Excellence Capital Campaign, a private funding initiative to bridge the gap between the balance sheet and the wish list. The campaign’s goal is to raise $3 million for things that would enhance the quality of education but fall outside of the budget, and another $3 million to establish a sustainable endowment.”
As a Lebo Citizens reader writes:
WRONG! WRONG! WRONG MTL MAGAZINE! THE DISTRICT LAUNCHED THE CAMPAIGN TO RAISE $6 MILLION IN 2013, NOT 2015 AS THE MAGAZINE CLAIMS. NEED PROOF, JUST LOOK AT THE DISTRICT’S FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE CAMPAIGN.
IF THE MAGAZINE IS GOING TO BE THE MAIN SOURCE OF INFO FOR THE COMMUNITY, IT SHOULD AT LEAST GET IT RIGHT!
Nick Meduho was aware of what was happening with the campaign. He maintained a soft-spoken, unassuming demeanor during Citizen Comments, quietly filing Right To Knows, and Mary Birks knew it. I am feeling overwhelmed with Nick's passing. I hope others will come forward to continue Nick's work.

Update November 1, 2017 5:11 PM Oops! She found it.
Dear Mrs. Gillen,

After I received your email I did locate the attached financial summary that was not originally with the PowerPoint, but was handed out to the Board.

Jeanine

I can see why it was not originally included. YIKES!!!!!!

Thursday, October 26, 2017

Latest Right To Know filed

I wanted to share an email that I received this morning. I did file a RTK because names will need to be redacted and that means that I won't receive the emails until 35 days from now, after the election.

I understand you request a lot of right-to-know documents from the school board. Did you hear about the racist graffiti found in the high school kitchen on February 1? No? Because it was immediately covered up without a police report? Maybe you could ask for emails to the school board on February 5th from a concerned citizen which included photos as well as Mary Birks response on February 6th.

The majority of the school board did not know about the graffiti until this citizen brought it to their attention. Mary knew. She hadn't told them. Why is that?

Thursday, October 12, 2017

So here is what I got for $1.25.

As I reported yesterday, I had to prepay $1.25 for missing receipts that should have been included in Nick M.'s RTK. See Getting nowhere quick! to read the ration of you know what that our disrespectful school board president dished out to me. Jeanine emailed the five receipts to me today. Here they are. Pursuant receipts

The five receipts must have come from the general fund. They are not earmarked Fund 27 Capital Campaign like the others were.

It was brought to my attention today to look at the footnote on Timmy's Capital Campaign Timeline

Jan Klein usually reports that the monthly bills are typical for this time of year. As we know from the school board president who is under investigation, items are approved through monthly bills without the school board directors taking the time to read the list of bills. Timmy always recommends that the monthly bills be approved.


I'm getting the feeling that the $923,530.02 loan/investment/heist is just the tip of the iceberg. How can these funds be co-mingled? How much money has actually been lost or mismanaged? Seriously, Jan Klein needs to go. We must hire different auditors. The school board needs to get rid of the Capital Campaign Director and her cabinet, even though Mary thinks it is a 100 year plan. They need to give Timmy his walking papers. Promote Dr. Davis to Superintendent. Go back to one assistant superintendent. Make "How to win friends and influence people" required reading for the board majority and the Timmy Ticket. And we need to get Mary Birks the heck out of there.

Wednesday, October 11, 2017

Times must be tough on Horsman Drive

This post is a continuation of Getting nowhere quick! from October 2-3.

Another RTK was granted in part and denied in part today. 

On October 4, 2017, the Mt. Lebanon School District (the “District") received your Public Records Request (“Request”), made pursuant to the Right to Know Law ("RTKL"), seeking “receipts for Pursuant Ketchum's invoice for $18,400 (up front expense) and receipts for the first four payments of $14,613.”  
Please be advised that the District has completed its review of your Request and your Request is granted and denied in part.  
The District has located five pages of paper records that are responsive to this Request. Under the Section 701 of the RTKL, the District is not required to create electronic records if the records do not exist in electronic format. Therefore, because these records do not exist in electronic format and because you request that responsive records be sent by email, your Request is denied. Friedman v. Upper Darby School District, AP 2017-0397, 2017 WL 1196380 (OOR March 28, 2017).  
However, the District will scan and email these records upon receipt of payment in the amount of $1.25 (5 pages x $0.25 per page) made payable to the “Mt. Lebanon School District.” Alternatively, the records will be made available for copying at a cost of $0.25 per page. 
Long story short, I went up to the Business Office with my $1.25 only to learn that Jeanine was gone for the day. I hope she will be able to send my request to me tomorrow.

Here is my receipt for $1.25. As I told the ladies in the Business Office, (never saw Jan Klein,) I didn't want to cause a financial hardship to the District. Times must be tough on Horsman Drive if they are expecting to be paid $1.25 up front.

Thursday, October 5, 2017

Timmy's Sampling of Community Opinion UPDATED 7:50 PM

Timmy's Key Communicators group has always intrigued me. Do a search on Lebo Citizens to get some background. Timmy likes to refer to it as a "sampling of community opinion." It helps him understand and proactively manage issues. Through a Right To Know, an updated list of members of Timmy's Super Secret Task Force is available here.

2016-2017 Key Communicators

Elaine Cappucci is back to help Timmy "understand" and "manage issues." Now I understand the Aviva Diamond Smear Campaign.

Update October 5, 2017 7:50 PM Timmy just retweeted:



Still waiting for Timmy's Timeline, which he and Mary Birks promised to put on the Capital Campaign website weeks ago. Yesterday, I ended up filing a RTK for it. 



Wednesday, October 4, 2017

He's trying, really trying


Appendix A

I would like to request the following:

An absolute complete/comprehensive and accurate income/expense report for the Century of Excellence Capital Campaign for dates January 1, 2012 thru September 15, 2017 which will include all the following;

#1 All revenues itemized including but not limited to dates, amount and source of each transaction being as specific as possible, I understand that specific donor names must be redacted.

#2 All expenditures itemized including but not limited to date, amount, payee and category of each transaction being as specific as possible.    

#3 All balance of money whether they be in a bank account, the Pittsburgh Foundation, etc. as of September 15, 2017.

#4 All itemized transfers of money with specific dates and amounts transferred back to and from the school district general account for the capital campaign account.  

Monday, September 25, 2017

Finally! Page 2

From another Right To Know.

The request: “I would like to request a comprehensive/complete and accurate financial report for the Century of Excellence Campaign covering from the inception date through August 31, 2017.”

Capital Campaign Financial Report through August 31, 2017 (2 pages)

This is what I had asked for, but never heard back from "Mary Birks, For the Board." This is what should be on the MLSD website, not the one page summary. Do you think it will be changed?

From 7/31 to 8/31 (one month), revenues equaled $1456.31. Expenditures equaled $6731.30, not including disbursements that totaled $19,843.94. Not good. Now we know why Jan Klein avoided posting page 2.

Statements from The Pittsburgh Foundation

 Right To Know Request:
I would like to request all reports (financial or other) received from the Pittsburgh Foundation regarding the investments from the Century of Excellence Campaign from periods January 1, 2017-August 31, 2017.
The request was granted and is available here.




List of funds are from here:
https://pittsburghfoundation.org/funds-master-list?page=6

Friday, May 26, 2017

The Municipality will be thrilled to hear this.

Mt. Lebanon residents do not have the right to know where lethal weapons are being discharged in Mt. Lebanon. The PA Supreme Court will not hear my case. My request has been denied.

Petition for Allowance of Appeal is denied per Supreme Court of Pennsylvania.

I want to thank those who contributed to my legal bills when the Municipality of Mt. Lebanon first took me to Common Pleas Court of Allegheny County to appeal the PA Office of Open Records' Final Determination.

The fact that the courts, from Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas all the way to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, do not believe that Mt. Lebanon residents have the right to know where lethal weapons are being fired in their neighborhoods is quite sad. Today, we take chances going to concerts, flying, and now, walking our dogs on the streets of Mt. Lebanon seven months out of the year.

Monday, May 22, 2017

Not what I asked for. UPDATED 3 TIMES

On May 15, 2017, I filed a Right To Know seeking "All records, including but not limited to emails, texts, and interoffice memos related to modifying the job posting dates for Middle School Social Studies Teacher - 8th Grade US History - Contract 2016-2017 JobID:471. Dates modified include: Date Posted & Closing Date."

Here is what I got.

Response Letter They located a copy of the job posting as it currently exists. No kidding!

The records sent (redacted, yet free of charge. How about that, Keith McGill and Bonnie Cross?!!)

The cover letter from MTLSD  - check out all the people who were cc'ed!

And finally, my response to the MTLSD ORO. I enclosed the original and modified job postings.

Timmy is not giving up the information!

Update May 22, 2017 6:12 PM If you read the fine print at the bottom of the redacted emails, it appears that M Mikesell applied for the position. According to the staff directory, Matthew Mikesell teaches Grade Six Social Studies at Mellon. http://www.mtlsd.org/page.cfm?p=632 Elaine Cappucci's son won out over an internal hire, a social studies teacher from Mellon.

Update May 23, 2017 5:46 PM I wrote back to Jeanine Szalinski, Timmy's administrative assistant/Open Records Officer asking for clarification concerning my RTK.  Well, that's all she wrote. That is all I am getting, even though it is not what I requested. So here are my options. Accept it at face value or appeal it to the PA Office of Open Records. Been there, done that. Still waiting for the PA Supreme Court to hear my case on the last appeal. I lost too much money on that deal, thinking that we have the right to know where lethal weapons are being fired in Mt. Lebanon. Ha! OR one of the million attorneys in Mt. Lebanon that isn't on Team Timmy can get a subpoena, or help me FOR FREE. I can file an appeal with the PA OOR, but their decision means nothing to Mt. Lebanon.

Update May 25, 2017 5:53 PM I decided to file an appeal with the PA Office of Open Records. Here is the correspondence MTLSD and I received today: the email and the confirmation letter from the Office of Open Records. I agreed to a thirty day extension, so their final determination will be on or before July 24, 2017.

Friday, December 9, 2016

Goliath won UPDATED

The deer haters and killers will be happy to hear...

O R D E R AND NOW, this 9th day of December, 2016, the decisions of May 23, 2016 of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas in the above-captioned matters are AFFIRMED.

Saving everyone from eleven pages of legalese, here it is - short and sweet:









What these means is that residents and visitors are not permitted to know where weapons are being fired in Mt. Lebanon, commissioners can wash their hands of any responsibility because it involves private individuals and not "government actors," and police officers like Officer James Hughes, who had an arsenal of 120 weapons too large to store in the Washington County Sheriff's Office and has a temporary PFA against him, can remain anonymous because he, if he was an archer, was donating his time to kill deer. We do not have the right to know where killing is taking place. We don't have the right to know who the killers are.

Mt. Lebanon police officers are exempt from any media reports, it appears. Had Officer Hughes been on some other police force, it would have been all over the news.

To appeal this decision, I would need to go to the State Supreme Court, IF the Supreme Court would hear the case. Small detail here - I don't have the funds. Mt. Lebanon commissioners won. They used our tax dollars to contract out the dirty work. Think about that when the commissioners vote to increase our taxes on Tuesday.

I tried my best to force the Municipality of Mt. Lebanon to be more transparent and make our neighborhoods safer, but their loyalty remains with the ten archers and twelve private property owners who "donated" to this deer killing program. The hell with the rest of us.

Update December 9, 2016 4:00 PM The Post-Gazette wasted no time publishing this.
Appellate court says Mt. Lebanon deer cull participants can remain private Still waiting for them to spill the beans about the Mt. Lebanon police officer, a member of the Dormont-Mt. Lebanon Sportsmen's Club and had his arsenal of 120 weapons confiscated by Washington County Sheriff's Office. We will never know if he was/is one of the archers.

Sunday, November 27, 2016

One year later...

Facebook reminded me of this "memory" from one year ago.

State orders Mt. Lebanon to provide locations of deer hunt

On Tuesday, the state Office of Open Records granted Ms. Gillen’s request for all communications to and from the municipal government concerning the controlled archery hunt. The information is to be released within 30 days. 
A Mt. Lebanon spokeswoman said the municipality had received the request but would not issue a statement until commissioners and staff could meet next week. The next commissioners meeting is scheduled for Dec. 8, but Susan Morgans said the Right-to-Know request will probably be discussed sooner.

Susan Morgans leaked the commissioners' decision to the PG, that they decided to take it to the Court of Common Pleas. I read about it in the newspaper.

The commissioners, of course, voted to take this to the Court of Common Pleas. From there, it went to Commonwealth Court. Knowing our commissioners, it will probably go all the way to the Sate Supreme Court, if they will hear it.

Friday, October 28, 2016

Another way to beat the RTK law?

Every week, the municipal manager publishes an administrative report. It is primarily for the commissioners, but also distributed to former commissioners, staff, etc., and provides a snapshot to the commissioners by department. This was sent out last week. Administrative Report #43 October 21, 2016

This one line caught my attention.




Intranet = a private network accessible only to an organization's staff.

I seem to remember reading something about an intranet communication involving last year's pancake breakfast. Or it was a retirement party. Grrr. Can't remember exactly what the event was.

I can understand the need for a benefits portal, but why would the Public Information Office need access to an intranet? Oh wait. I know. One of the finest ladies in Mt. Lebanon is transparent enough.

When filing RTKs, don't forget to ask for intranet communications, texts, emails...