Showing posts with label Sports Advisory Board. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sports Advisory Board. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 5, 2018
Monday, June 5, 2017
Mt. Lebanon continues to be defiant
Every year, our public officials and public employees are required to file a Statement of Financial Interests with the Municipality or School District, as well as with the PA Ethics Commission. Here are the Municipal Statements of Financial Interests May 2017.
According to the Guide to the PA Public Official and Employee Ethics Act, The State defines public officials as :
Mark Quealy, Mt. Lebanon Parking Enforcement Supervisor
Blaise Larotonda
Members of the Historic Preservation Board who have spent $25,000 on Virginia Manor remodeling guides, and brick road recommendations.
Sports Advisory Board, the most powerful board in the Municipality, now are MIA. Their meetings are constantly being canceled. The latest posted minutes are from January 5, 2017.
Mt. Lebanon continues to become more and more defiant. Just ask the Allegheny County Health Department concerning baiting and toxic dust emissions, Scott Township about killing in Twin Hills, PA Office of Open Records, and now the PA Ethics Commission.
According to the Guide to the PA Public Official and Employee Ethics Act, The State defines public officials as :
Any person elected by the public or elected or appointed by a governmental body or an appointed official in the executive, legislative or judicial branch of this Commonwealth or any political subdivision thereof, provided that it shall not include members of advisory boards that have no authority to expend public funds other than reimbursement for personal expense or to otherwise exercise the power of the State or any political subdivision thereof.Former manager Steve Feller was a stickler when it came to filing SFI's. Our new manager Keith McGill, not so much. We already know that Andrew McCreery and Susan Morgans made critical errors on their SFI's. At one time, members of these boards submitted SFI's. http://mtlebanon.org/63/Agendas-Minutes What I am noticing now is the number of SFI's which are no longer filed. Missing in action include:
Mark Quealy, Mt. Lebanon Parking Enforcement Supervisor
Blaise Larotonda
Members of the Historic Preservation Board who have spent $25,000 on Virginia Manor remodeling guides, and brick road recommendations.
Sports Advisory Board, the most powerful board in the Municipality, now are MIA. Their meetings are constantly being canceled. The latest posted minutes are from January 5, 2017.
Mt. Lebanon continues to become more and more defiant. Just ask the Allegheny County Health Department concerning baiting and toxic dust emissions, Scott Township about killing in Twin Hills, PA Office of Open Records, and now the PA Ethics Commission.
Sunday, January 8, 2017
Priorities and another service eliminated UPDATED
From the Manager's Recommended 2017 Budget page 6 - recommended on November 1, 2016:
At the October 3, 2013 Sports Advisory Board meeting, the condition of the aging ice rink was brought to the SAB's attention. Additionally, Commissioner John Bendel addressed the SAB members and asked how they wanted to spend their pot of gold. It was on the meeting video, but for some strange reason, that video is no longer available on the Mt. Lebanon website. Of course.
John Bendel went around the room and asked each member how they wanted to spend the remaining funds from the original $829,000 unassigned funds. The minutes show that the "consensus on the board was that Middle and Wildcat fields would be the preferred location."
Apparently getting the turf passed was more important that the ice rink. Priorities.
At the October 3, 2013 Sports Advisory Board meeting, the condition of the aging ice rink was brought to the SAB's attention. Additionally, Commissioner John Bendel addressed the SAB members and asked how they wanted to spend their pot of gold. It was on the meeting video, but for some strange reason, that video is no longer available on the Mt. Lebanon website. Of course.
However, I have the link to that video from a blog posting:
Update November 3, 2014 3:19 PM In addition to the videos that Albert Turfstein provided, please view the October 3, 2013 Sports Advisory Board Meeting. Click on Turf Project and watch Tim White say, "Mr. Bendel pissed away all the money we had."
John Bendel went around the room and asked each member how they wanted to spend the remaining funds from the original $829,000 unassigned funds. The minutes show that the "consensus on the board was that Middle and Wildcat fields would be the preferred location."
Another service no longer provided by the Municipality is their notary service.
Keep cutting back on services, Mt. Lebanon, but take care of the special interest groups. Kill those deer. Turf those fields. Ignore the ice rink which is enjoyed by the public. Eliminate our solid waste collection service. Great job.
Update January 8, 2017 7:29 PM I forgot to include the bids for the ice rink. Alternates are also listed. Keith McGill added, "The probable opinion of cost was developed by Gateway Engineers in conjunction with Stantec who is consulting on the project."
Update January 8, 2017 7:29 PM I forgot to include the bids for the ice rink. Alternates are also listed. Keith McGill added, "The probable opinion of cost was developed by Gateway Engineers in conjunction with Stantec who is consulting on the project."
Thursday, January 22, 2015
Her shoes melted.
Last time I had one of these was two years ago. Call it my meltdown I guess this is "Call it my meltdown 2.0." A friend sent me another article about the dangers of artificial turf. Is Artificial Turf Safe for Your Children? Jenny Chamberlain, a Los Angeles mother, avoids artificial turf because her child's shoes kept melting from the heat that artificial turf gives off.
I wrote to Manager Steve Feller, and copied the police chief, PIO, commissioners, and Rep. Dan Miller today asking when the public was going to be told about the archery program extension being denied and heard nothing back from Mr. Feller. In a Mt. Lebanon Google alert, I learned that Matt Santoni asked the same question. At least he got an answer. Mt. Lebanon awaits formal letter nixing extended deer season In the meantime, Kristen Linfante's favorite paint experts have signs near their registers promoting deer culling. They couldn't say no to the three pushy women who were approaching Washington Road storefronts. I tried to inform the community about how we are being bullied, but the bullies won. [See Call it my meltdown.]
Speaking of Kristen Linfante, I saw this on Facebook tonight.
I really need a vacation from this place. It is a horrible place to be right now.
Turf companies claim artificial turf is safe because kids don’t ingest the crumb rubber. Chamberlain, however, doesn’t buy it because she has seen kids drop an orange, brush it off and eat it—putting them at risk of exposure. Kids also fall on the ground constantly in sports and risk ingesting the crumb rubber that way, too.Yet, the SAB AHs all think that our concerns are "much ado about nothing." Watch the SAB video and you can see them all nod in agreement with the SAB AH who made that statement. I tried to inform the community about how we are being bullied, but the bullies won. [See Call it my meltdown.]
I wrote to Manager Steve Feller, and copied the police chief, PIO, commissioners, and Rep. Dan Miller today asking when the public was going to be told about the archery program extension being denied and heard nothing back from Mr. Feller. In a Mt. Lebanon Google alert, I learned that Matt Santoni asked the same question. At least he got an answer. Mt. Lebanon awaits formal letter nixing extended deer season In the meantime, Kristen Linfante's favorite paint experts have signs near their registers promoting deer culling. They couldn't say no to the three pushy women who were approaching Washington Road storefronts. I tried to inform the community about how we are being bullied, but the bullies won. [See Call it my meltdown.]
Speaking of Kristen Linfante, I saw this on Facebook tonight.
I was reminded of this Lebo Citizens comment.
Mrs. Linfante won't give up her elephant ivory bow. She considers it an extension of her arm. http://www.post-gazette.com/news/environment/2015/01/18/How-tiny-bits-of-ivory-snare-symphony-musicians-crossing-borders/stories/201501180065Kristen is just itching to have the deer killed with that loathsome slaughterhouse killing method called trap and bolt. Why would she ever want to give up her viola bow when she travels outside of the country? I tried to inform the community about how we are being bullied, but the bullies won. [See Call it my meltdown.]
I really need a vacation from this place. It is a horrible place to be right now.
Tuesday, January 20, 2015
Sports Advisory Board November meeting minutes finally posted
On Monday, I wrote to the commission asking about the SAB meeting minutes being posted. At that time, the June 2014 meeting minutes were the most recent ones available. I received this response from President John Bendel:
The November minutes have been posted. Minutes of the November 6, 2014 Sports Advisory Board meeting
The Sports Advisory Board met again on january 15, 2015. At approximately the 32:19 minute mark of the video, Dave Franklin was blaming the delay of the construction on those who wanted to stop the project. All it did, according to Dave, was cost the municipality more money and "it was much ado about nothing." Last I read, the Allegheny County Conservation District and the DEP would disagree with you, Dave. Gateway had to comply. The NPDES permit wasn't granted until October 16, 2014. Gateway told you that it would be the beginning of July. Don't blame us for it. Blame Gateway. Thanks for giving us so much credit, but we had nothing to do with it. Our protests were on October 26, 2014 and November 8, 2014. Construction was due to start August 1 and didn't begin until late October.
By the way, SAB, I guess this is "more ado about nothing."
Rep. Steve Israel Blasts Feds for Failing to Probe Synthetic Turf
Elaine,Maybe the questions to Mr. Bendel should be, "Why does the board with the largest budget ever recorded in Mt Lebanon history have gaps of over five months between meetings? If the board's needs are so essential, why the long vacation?"
Meeting minutes are posted after they are approved. Therefore, the postings have at least a one month delay. In the case of the SAB, they met on June 14, November 6 and January 15. The November 6 minutes were approved a few days ago at the January 15 meeting. They should be posted shortly.
The November minutes have been posted. Minutes of the November 6, 2014 Sports Advisory Board meeting
Mr. Franklin suggested that the policy be adjusted to reflect any changes to the field signage ordinance. He added that he doesn’t anticipate a great deal of interest from corporate sponsors.In April 2012, Lebo Fields' Dave Franklin had insisted that we must change the sign ordinance. Franklin on sign ordinance
Ideally, the municipality or the various sports associations will be permitted to sell tasteful sponsorship signage at the municipal fields (picture signs on the outfield fence at Dixon). These funds can then be applied to field maintenance and improvements. I think the first proposed amendment has a few problems, but we also need to encourage the commissioners to stay focused on getting the amendment right so that we can capitalize on this much needed source of additional revenue.
By the way, SAB, I guess this is "more ado about nothing."
Rep. Steve Israel Blasts Feds for Failing to Probe Synthetic Turf
A New York congressman is demanding the feds probe whether a type of synthetic turf used on thousands of kids' playing fields could cause health risks, saying that environmental officials have "whiffle-waffled" about the potential dangers.
Rep. Steve Israel of Long Island has sent a letter to the Environmental Protection Agency asking for a second look at the recycled material known as "tire crumb."...The EPA has said it does not have any plans to re-examine the risks.
"The EPA has just whiffle-waffled on this and they owe us a straight answer and they owe us that answer now," Israel said.
Friday, December 26, 2014
About those non-municipal funds...
To bring any new Lebo Citizen readers up to speed, Mt. Lebanon commissioners made an agreement with the Sports Advisory Board concerning the funding of the toxic turf at Wildcat and Middle Fields. 75% municipal funds and 25% non-municipal funds. The financial proposal was never put in writing in any commission minutes. It was stated in the mtl Magazine article, field fundraising underway, that the non-municipal share would be $250,000, not 25% of the project as originally proposed. Donations were held by the Mt. Lebanon Community Endowment for a small fee. The identity of the donors were never made public.
Earlier this week, Mayor Peduto came under fire when anonymous donations were made on a recent episode of "Undercover Boss." 'Boss' gifts to Pittsburgh employees from Peduto raise questions
Peduto promises to disclose identities of "Undercover Boss" donors
“They should disclose the donors to reassure the public that (donors) won't end up getting grants and contracts based on their benevolence.We know that Gateway Engineers made out well by donating at least $4,000 to the turf project. That's for another post. Stay tuned.
Peduto promises to disclose identities of "Undercover Boss" donors
Barry Kauffman, executive director of Pennsylvania Common Cause, said Peduto is obligated to share the information in the interest of transparency. Even though the money is coming from private donors, it's being funneled through a public agency.Lebo Citizen readers were made aware of missing Mt. Lebanon sports organizations' 990's in these posts about 990s. I called for better transparency. I see that I am not alone. Watchdogs call for better transparency of nonprofits' IRS filings
So, President Elect John Bendel and Sports Advisory Board commission liaison, when are you going to share the information in the interest of transparency?
Sunday, December 14, 2014
Just when the prayers were kicking in
On February 28, 2012, former school board president, Josephine Posti told me that she was praying for me. Apology To Josephine Posti It took some time for her prayers to kick in, but they did. Early this morning, I mailed Holiday Greetings to Timmy, various school board members past and present, my favorite commissioners, and members of the Sports Advisory Board. Lo and behold, a water main break occurred at the post office on Castle Shannon Blvd this morning.
Josephine Post, spokeswoman for Pennsylvania American Water was on the scene. Jo, were you able to salvage my greeting cards?
Mt. Lebanon water main break to result in 'significant' damage to garage
Here is a video of the flooding.
Timmy, Mary, Elaine, Eddie, Kristen, John, Steve, Dave, Dave, Dave, Dave, Dave, Dave, (can never have too many Daves) He Who Shall Not Be Named, and Jo, Merry Christmas and Happy Hanukkah. My card was in the mail. ;)
| TRAFFIC ADVISORY 12/14/14 11:01 | (MT LEBANON TOWNSHIP - 460.625) FIRE DEPARTMENT WITH MAJOR WATER BREAK, POST OFFICE AND SEVERAL VEHICLE IMPACTED, REQUEST PAWC [PEN084] |
Josephine Post, spokeswoman for Pennsylvania American Water was on the scene. Jo, were you able to salvage my greeting cards?
Mt. Lebanon water main break to result in 'significant' damage to garage
Here is a video of the flooding.
Timmy, Mary, Elaine, Eddie, Kristen, John, Steve, Dave, Dave, Dave, Dave, Dave, Dave, (can never have too many Daves) He Who Shall Not Be Named, and Jo, Merry Christmas and Happy Hanukkah. My card was in the mail. ;)
Friday, June 6, 2014
Dave on Artificial Turf: Proven Safe!
Remember this exchange between Charlotte Stephenson and Dave Brumfield?
From: David Brumfield <dbrumfield@mtlebanon.org>
Date: May 3, 2014 5:06:53 PM EDT
To: Charlotte Stephenson
Cc: Commission <commission@mtlebanon.org>
Subject: Re: Studies
Date: May 3, 2014 5:06:53 PM EDT
To: Charlotte Stephenson
Cc: Commission <commission@mtlebanon.org>
Subject: Re: Studies
Ms. Stephenson,
Please find attached links to the studies I have mentioned to a few residents.
There are of course others, but I believe these are the only studies I referenced to residents or at meetings.
Additionally, though I do not believe I referenced them there are a number of studies that show turf is equal to or better than natural grass as to likelihood of athletic injury.
Dave Brumfield
Please find attached links to the studies I have mentioned to a few residents.
http://www.cpsc.gov/en/Newsroom/News-Releases/2008/CPSC-Staff-Finds-Synthetic-Turf-Fields-OK-to-Install-OK-to-Play-On/
http://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.syntheticturfcouncil.org/resource/resmgr/docs/nysdec_study_on_leaching_off.pdf
http://c.ymcdn.com/sites/www.syntheticturfcouncil.org/resource/resmgr/docs/dr._johns-bainbridge_island_.pdf
Additionally, though I do not believe I referenced them there are a number of studies that show turf is equal to or better than natural grass as to likelihood of athletic injury.
Dave Brumfield
*********
I forwarded Dave Brumfield's links to Dr. Phil Johnson, one of the speakers from the April 30 Educational Forum on Turf, from which John Bendel left early.
Here is Dr. Johnson's response:
To: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>; dbrumfield <dbrumfield@mtlebanon.org>; stephensoncs ; commission <commission@mtlebanon.org>
Sent: Tue, Jun 3, 2014 10:10 AM
Subject: RE: Studies
I have reviewed each link provided below.
(The Manex Consulting study did not include direct access, however, only a press release.)
My main area of focus is limited to possible human exposures and health risk.
Regarding the EPA study, please note that EPA recently retracted its 2009 press release from the agency’s study.
Below are my summarized findings.
Sincerely,
Phil Johnson, PhD, MPH, MESc
Mt. Lebanon
Summarized findings:
(1) The studies collectively indicate (e.g., in their methods and limitations sections) that sampled fields and materials cannot be extrapolated. Findings cannot be extended beyond the particular study sites and used to reach broad conclusions with respect to other fields because these studies are not representative.
A variety of reasons contribute to this outcome, including:
a. Wide diversity of materials and ingredients in fields (studies are only specific to areas studied);
b. Diversity of construction;
c. Diversity and variability of real-world factors including ambient weatherizing (e.g., solar radiation) and wear conditions (e.g., physical activity patterns); and
d. Variation with respect to components monitored, sites sampled and samples taken.
In order to determine whether the proposed fields in Mt. Lebanon may pose a health risk to humans – and especially to our susceptible populations – decision makers and the community require (a) full and complete lists of ingredients and materials in the artificial fields (including fill and synthetic grass blades) and (b) full and complete lists of ingredients and materials to be used to maintain the artificial fields, including for example any pesticides, biocides or cleaning agents.
With this information in hand, the community and its leadership can begin a process to ascertain potential exposures and the possibility of associated adverse health effects to humans on and using the fields toward a deliberative decision-making process about whether to undertake an activity with the potential to harm public health.
Without this information, there is no way to characterize public health risk and make an informed decision because information will be incomplete, limited and subject to excess uncertainty.
Given this uncertainty, the health and well-being of our populations – including pregnant persons, infants, children, those with respiratory disease including asthma, those with allergies, those with neurodisabilities or disorders; those with cancer or surviving cancer; and those at risk of developing cancer – may be at risk.
(2) Overall, with respect to human exposures and ability to develop risk analysis, the studies collectively either report or do not mention significant methodological limitations, including:
a. As noted above, cannot extrapolate findings to other fields: the studies are acknowledged as non-representative.
b. Do not adequately quantify the potential for exposures to some susceptible human populations such as neonatal populations, persons with neurodevelopmental disorders and diseased populations;
c. Do not adequately simulate real-world exposure conditions – including sustained and diverse physical activity, as well as field disturbance (e.g., compression and degradation) under a range of conditions (e.g., field age, solar radiation) that may affect release of chemicals into the environment;
d. Do not consider multiple possible chemical exposures that field users would experience from the many possible chemical ingredients in the fields or used to maintain the fields;
e. Provide inadequate simulation of typical field use and condition factors in both core field and ambient air;
f. Do not adequately sample for worst-case exposures from newly installed fields;
g. Do not adequately address potential for chemical exposure synergies and interactive effects;
h. Do not adequately focus on possible chemicals (such as lead) in synthetic turf fibers/blades;
i. Focus only on one component of the field (such as infill crumbs), and within this subset are unable to consider diversity of such components among other fields;
j. Do not adequately consider chemicals and other materials used to maintain fields;
k. Use averaged threshold values to screen out reported measured chemical concentrations rather than full distributions including peaks – and therefore eliminate relevant data from further evaluation;
l. Have limited or no VOC and SVOC sampling;
m. Rely on air sampling techniques limited by variability of monitors, short duration sampling and staff activity interference; and
n. Recommend further study given limitations and inadequacies.
*********
I am trying a new way to share the podcast of the June 5, 2014 Sports Advisory Board Meeting.
I have also uploaded the podcast to Lebo Citizens and is available here. The SAB threw residents to the wolves during Citizen Comments. There were three residents who spoke. The first resident was told that there will be no more super secret Turf Project Task Force meetings. Their work is done. Dave Franklin said that they are at $245,000. The second resident had shared her followup research with the Parks Advisory Board, which the PAB liaison Dave Franklin chose not to share with the SAB. She tried to share her research with the SAB. She instead was met with hostility. What a group. The third resident was able to get the breakdown from Franklin. The $245,000 is made up of $125,000 pledged by the Sports Associations, $93,000 in cash, and $27,000 in corporate commitments with $5,000 of that $27,000 will be paid in December.
It was announced that there will be only Dr. Andrew McNitt with no mention of a toxicologist at the June 12 meeting. This is the PIO Press Release. Do you see the words "artificial turf" ANYWHERE in the press release or on the municipal website? Nope. Not there.
Wednesday, May 14, 2014
Gateway is billing us $1,000 per meeting! UPDATED 4X
I am not an attorney. Everyone knows that, but I think I have pretty good instincts when something isn't right. From the Lebo Citizens post, Bullied again on April 24, 2014, two residents tried to attend the Turf Project Task Force meeting, which was held immediately after the "not for the general public" public meeting at the concession stand. They were told by members of the super secret task force that it was not a public meeting. The two residents said that they would just like to observe and took two meeting agendas. These two residents were told to return the agendas and were asked to leave. Members of this super secret turf project task force include Dave Franklin, "He Who Shall Not Be Named," MTLSD Athletic Director John Grogan, Recreation Director David Donnellan, Landscape Architect Jim Sauer from J.T. Sauer, and Municipal Engineer from Gateway, Dan Deiseroth. According to the January 9, 2014 SAB meeting minutes*, Gateway Engineering contributed $4000 for the Middle and Wildcat Turf Project.
Keep in mind, Gateway's Dan Deiseroth claimed that the fields on Cedar Blvd. never flood.
It turns out that Gateway Engineering is charging Mt. Lebanon $1,000 per Turf Project Task Force meeting. There have been seven meetings, and we have been billed $7,000.
The following is the May 2, 2014 memo that Dan Deiseroth sent to Steve Feller concerning the Turf Project Fees expended.
Something that has been overlooked for several meetings now, is the Turf Project Task Force Financial Report. John Bendel had promised to share that information a month ago. It still hasn't happened. Kelly Fraasch was kind enough to share this "report" with me this morning.
Why is everything such a secret? Why weren't the financial reports given at the commission meetings? Why are residents being asked to leave the Turf Project Task Force? Why did Dave Brumfield freak out at the commission discussion session when Kelly Fraasch brought up the topic of residents attending the Turf Project Task Force meetings? Why is it being left up to John Bendel to decide? Why are there so many unanswered questions concerning this turf project?
I have asked the commission for a draft of the bid that is going out tomorrow, May 15. Kelly Fraasch copied me when she asked for a copy of the draft. So far, nothing.
I understand that there is a process in which taxpayers can pay their taxes in protest, with a portion of the funds going into an escrow account. This pertains to assessments. All you Mt. Lebanon attorneys who are not involved with the Sports Advisory Board, would you check to see if we can do the same with this turf project? I am not seeing overwhelming support. Residents are against it for financial reasons, environmental reasons, health and safety of our young athletes, as well as the arrogance, misrepresentation and lack of respect from our elected officials who are being dishonest every step of the way.
*February 6, 2014 SAB meeting minutes are the latest posted minutes on the municipal website.
Update May 14, 2014 11:43 PM I asked again for a draft of the bid that is going out tomorrow. Clarification on the specifics of the bid package It turns out that the 15th deadline was for JT Sauer to submit the plans to Gateway to coordinate and check and incorporate with other bid documents.
Update May 15, 2014 10:58 PM Mt. Lebanon residents criticize 'newcomers tax,' turf project for fields
Update May 15, 2014 11:24 PM See page 13 of John Bendel's Field Enhancement presentation listed in this post, New street signs in Mt. Lebanon, Gateway Engineers' Opinion of Cost for Contingency/Soft Costs is listed as $89,070. Yet, Gateway's costs shown above are estimated at $100,997 and growing.
Update May 16, 2014 8:06 PM After an entire day of rain yesterday, it's Play Ball at Middle Field tonight.
Keep in mind, Gateway's Dan Deiseroth claimed that the fields on Cedar Blvd. never flood.
It turns out that Gateway Engineering is charging Mt. Lebanon $1,000 per Turf Project Task Force meeting. There have been seven meetings, and we have been billed $7,000.
The following is the May 2, 2014 memo that Dan Deiseroth sent to Steve Feller concerning the Turf Project Fees expended.
Something that has been overlooked for several meetings now, is the Turf Project Task Force Financial Report. John Bendel had promised to share that information a month ago. It still hasn't happened. Kelly Fraasch was kind enough to share this "report" with me this morning.
From: Kelly Fraasch <kfraasch@mtlebanon.org>
To: egillen476 <egillen476@aol.com>; Stephen Feller <sfeller@mtlebanon.org>
Cc: commission <commission@mtlebanon.org>
Subject: Re: SAB financial report
Date: Wed, May 14, 2014 10:12 am
This is what I got via email last night.
See below.
FYI, I did ask for a further breakdown and hope to get it soon.
K
Committed by Sports Associations $124,500
(this is an increase of $26,500 from the last update and reflects additional funds from lacrosse, baseball and football)
Paid into Endowment as of 5/13/14 $65,389
Checks received by Mt. Lebo Lacrosse to be provided to Endowment $26,500
Other sources (Parents Athletic Council, corporate donations, etc) $17,250
Total to date $233,639
On Wed, May 14, 2014 at 9:16 AM, 'egillen476@aol.com' via Commission <commission@mtlebanon.org> wrote:A resident told me last night that the sports associations are emptying their piggy banks to fund this project without giving notice to parents. Also, please note that there is no mention of the "largest donation made by Soccer," according to Dave Franklin. Also, I am confused as to what is the cash in hand balance.
Commissioners,
Where was the financial report from the SAB? They still haven't given us the break down as to cash in hand and pledges to date. John Bendel assured me that it would be given in the next meeting. That was two meetings ago.
Elaine Gillen
Why is everything such a secret? Why weren't the financial reports given at the commission meetings? Why are residents being asked to leave the Turf Project Task Force? Why did Dave Brumfield freak out at the commission discussion session when Kelly Fraasch brought up the topic of residents attending the Turf Project Task Force meetings? Why is it being left up to John Bendel to decide? Why are there so many unanswered questions concerning this turf project?
I have asked the commission for a draft of the bid that is going out tomorrow, May 15. Kelly Fraasch copied me when she asked for a copy of the draft. So far, nothing.
I understand that there is a process in which taxpayers can pay their taxes in protest, with a portion of the funds going into an escrow account. This pertains to assessments. All you Mt. Lebanon attorneys who are not involved with the Sports Advisory Board, would you check to see if we can do the same with this turf project? I am not seeing overwhelming support. Residents are against it for financial reasons, environmental reasons, health and safety of our young athletes, as well as the arrogance, misrepresentation and lack of respect from our elected officials who are being dishonest every step of the way.
 |
| 4:30 on a Wednesday afternoon in May w/ near perfect weather and... All fields are empty. |
*February 6, 2014 SAB meeting minutes are the latest posted minutes on the municipal website.
Update May 14, 2014 11:43 PM I asked again for a draft of the bid that is going out tomorrow. Clarification on the specifics of the bid package It turns out that the 15th deadline was for JT Sauer to submit the plans to Gateway to coordinate and check and incorporate with other bid documents.
Update May 15, 2014 10:58 PM Mt. Lebanon residents criticize 'newcomers tax,' turf project for fields
Update May 15, 2014 11:24 PM See page 13 of John Bendel's Field Enhancement presentation listed in this post, New street signs in Mt. Lebanon, Gateway Engineers' Opinion of Cost for Contingency/Soft Costs is listed as $89,070. Yet, Gateway's costs shown above are estimated at $100,997 and growing.
Update May 16, 2014 8:06 PM After an entire day of rain yesterday, it's Play Ball at Middle Field tonight.
 |
| Middle Field 05.16.14 at 6:00 PM |
Monday, May 12, 2014
Bendel on Turf
Please sign this petition if you want to halt public funds for use of artificial turf at Wildcat and Middle Fields.
Here is an exchange that showed up in my mailbox. Please read what Commissioner Bendel has to say to one of his constituents.
From: John Bendel <jbendel@mtlebanon.org>
Sent: Mon, May 12, 2014 9:10 am
Subject: Re: artificial turf
Thank you for contacting me about the turf project.
The turf project approved for Middle/Wildcat field (MWC) field in Mt. Lebanon is the culmination of many years of discussion, analysis and research to address the shortage of field space. Addressing the shortage of fields has been a long-standing priority for our community, and over the last decade there have been multiple attempts to expand the number fields and/or increase the use (the number of games/practices) on existing fields. However, until the MWC project, no significant enhancements have been implemented to address this priority.
Most fields in Mt. Lebanon are diamond-based, which are designed primarily for baseball and softball. Over the last decade or so, the popularity of the sports using rectangular-based fields such as lacrosse, soccer and field hockey has increased significantly. Therefore, the focus of field enhancements has been to expand the number of rectangular-based fields.
Information on the approved turf project - description, concept plan and a variety of presentations, can be found on the Municipal website at:
http://mtlebanon.org/index.aspx?NID=2199
I support the project because it:
- Increases field slots available by 60%; turf will withstand continuous use
- Benefits many residents - there were 3,600 total registrations in field-based youth sports programs in 2013, plus many more residents involved on School District sports teams
- Is supported by all field sports associations
- Includes non-municipal contributions of $250,000 toward the $1 million initial capital cost, and requires a use fee that will pay for a portion of the field replacement cost
- Involves a partnership with the School District whereby the District will maintain the field (reducing maintenance cost to the Municipality by almost $14,000 annually compared to the current maintenance cost. The estimated annual maintenance cost for the School District is $7,000, a net saving to the tax payers of $7,000 per year); and in return the District’s sports teams will have use of the field
- Leverages existing access, parking, restrooms, concessions and lights at MWC
With respect the health and safety issues relative to a new turf field, Mt. Lebanon is able to draw upon about 40 years of direct experience. Turf was first installed in Mt. Lebanon in the 1970s. In fact, over that period, we have the experience of a variety of different and improved turf products as they have evolved over the years. Therefore, as the Municipality has evaluated turf generally, as well as the specific turf products currently under consideration for Middle and Wildcat, we have relied upon the following criteria: (1) specific experiences in Mt. Lebanon, (2) independent testing under conditions that are similar to those present in Mt. Lebanon, (3) information provided by governmental agencies (Department of Environmental Protection, etc.), and (4) other information that is widely accepted as independent and credible.
Field enhancements and this project have been discussed in public meetings, included in long-range and short-range plans for many years. I have prepared the follow summary to put the long history of this project in perspective.
My historical knowledge doesn't go back as far as others, but I know that the land purchases at McNeilly and Twin Hills were intended, at least in part, to expand our athletic fields. For a variety of reasons, primarily cost related, the fields were never developed at these locations.
The Municipality's priority for field enhancements is well documented. The Municipality's annual Capital Improvements Plan (CIP), which is our five-year plan for identifying priority projects, has included field development for many years. In fact, the turf project has been included in the last six CIPs beginning in 2009. The CIP is recommended annually by the Planning Board and approved by the Commission, and is discussed at several meetings each year at the Planning Board and Commission. All of these meetings are open to the public and the Commission meetings are video recorded.
In addition, the recently adopted 2013 Comprehensive Plan (Plan), which is our community's planning and development guide for the next 10 years, specifically includes the turf project as a priority. The Plan development included significant opportunity for resident and stakeholder participation. A core planning team made up of a cross-section of representatives of boards and authorities led the process, and a variety of sub-teams focused on specific issues. The opportunity for public input was provided multiple times via a variety of means throughout the 18 month long planning process. The Plan was recommended by the Planning Board and approved by the Commission in 2013.
More recently, in 2012-14, the Commission established recreation and field improvements as a high priority during its annual goal setting retreats. As a result, the Commission has made significant capital investments in recreation facilities in recent years - pool improvements, tennis center (lighting at two courts, concrete stairs and sidewalks and renovations at the tennis center building), several neighborhood park projects, upgrades to the recreation center and ice rink and new equipment (lawn mower at golf course and electric Zamboni). Additional recreation enhancements at Robb Hollow and Northmeadowcroft Park are in the planning phase. Despite this cumulative multi-million dollar investment in recreation, the Municipality has done little to address the long-standing priority for field enhancements.
Since 2012, several field enhancement alternatives have been evaluated by the Commission. The assessment of field options was completed parallel with the development of the Comprehensive Plan as was the case for several other community priorities. If fact, several goals in the Plan are already complete and many more are in the development and planning stages. The Commission began addressing the lack of field space by assessing the opportunities to increase use of its existing fields. Options such as resting fields to improve conditions and better drainage were considered. The Commission did invest in better drainage at Bird field in 2012. With the high demand for field space, the ability to rest fields was not considered a viable option.
The Commission next looked at creating new field space, which is difficult in a highly developed community like Mt. Lebanon. On March 13, 2012, with the assistance of Gateway Engineering, at a discussion session, the Commission reviewed the alternatives listed below. Gateway's presentation can be found at http://mtlebanon.org/DocumentCenter/Home/View/2660
- McNeilly - $3-4 million, multi-field development
- Robb Hollow - Three fields, one on the upper section and two near the Public Works area along Cedar
- Twin Hills - one field
- Brafferton - drainage improvements and conversion from a diamond-based baseball field to rectangle field
- Turfing of MWC and Mellon
The field enhancement alternatives presented in March 2012, were the subject of discussion at various times throughout 2012 and 2013. The projects at McNeilly and Twin Hills were not supported by the Commission and were not pursued. The McNeilly project was not considered viable for several reasons, including the $3-4 million cost and the distance from most areas of the Municipality. The proposed field at Twin Hills was not considered due to its relatively small size, access issues and other development constraints.
The Municipality continued its evaluation of the Robb Hollow, Brafferton and turf options.
Robb Hollow - after additional discussion, the upper field at Robb Hollow was considered the best option at that location. The project in the upper section of Robb Hollow included a full-sized field and unlike the proposed fields along Cedar, it did not encroach on the area used by Public Works. This project was discussed multiple times in 2012, including October 9 and 22. The Municipality completed additional engineering work on the proposed upper field. In late-2012 the Commission decided not to pursue the upper field development due to the rising cost estimate of at least $1.3 million, which included field development, access, parking and transfer of leaf processing to a new location. It was estimated that the transfer of the leaf processing would add approximately $30,000 annually to annual operating expenses. The project would have resulted in the loss of nearly 7 acres of trees, created steep slopes due to excavation and was to be built in close proximity to homes in an adjoining neighborhood.
Brafferton - the Commission approved $197,400 for improvements to Brafferton in 2012. The proposal was to make drainage improvements, remove the baseball diamond and convert the surface to a rectangular field. The Commission reviewed this project multiple times during discussion sessions in 2012 and 2013. The project recognized the need to add an access road and parking to accommodate this new configuration. The access road and parking were estimated to cost an additional $133,000. The newly formed Sports Advisory Board (SAB) and the Commission supported this project. On September 17, 2013 the Brafferton bidding process resulted in one bidder submitting a bid of $845,000 for a large field plus parking and access road (alternate 2A). The Commission rejected this bid due to the high cost and has not pursued this project since that time.
Turf - as noted above, the turf project has been in the Municipality's CIP every year since 2009. The engineer's opinion of probable cost has roughly been around $1 million for the turfing of either Mellon or MWC. The sports community has supported a turf project for many years. On June 25, 2012, the Youth Sports Alliance (YSA), which at the time represented all field based sports in Mt. Lebanon, presented a proposal to turf and add lighting to MWC at a public meeting. On July 10, 2012 the Commission had a follow-up discussion on the YSA proposal. On July 23, 2012 a presentation opposing the turf project was made to the Commission.
A series of Commission discussion sessions on August 27, September 11, September 24, 2012, included the use of the Municipality’s unassigned fund balance for capital projects. Field enhancements were part of these discussions.
On November 26, 2012, the Commission unanimously voted to form the SAB (refer to the purpose statement below). The creation of the SAB provided an opportunity to have a board focused on enhancing the recreational facilities and services in Mt. Lebanon. Boards and authorities exist 1) To discuss/assess specific issues in greater detail than is possible at Commission meetings, and 2) To make recommendations to the Commission on issues important to the community. The SAB's members were appointed by the Commission in early 2013.
Since its first meeting in March 2013 through April 2014, the SAB has discussed field improvements at seven meetings, in particular the Brafferton and turf projects. On June 6, 2013, the SAB voted to recommend a turf project to the Commission as its highest priority. At the SAB's October 3 and November 7, 2013 meetings the SAB voted to recommend the MWC turf project for the Commission's approval. The SAB's recommendations to support the turf project were presented to the Commission on June 24, November 12 and November 25, 2013. All of the SAB meetings are open to the public and are video recorded.
SAB's Purpose
- Review and assess all sports-related facilities and services in Mt. Lebanon.
- Recommend possible changes and improvements to sports-related facilities and services.
- Assist in the continued safe provision of athletic opportunities to Mt. Lebanon residents.
- Receive and consider public comment and other public input regarding sports facilities and services.
- Support, promote and/or provide programs and services to assist athletes and coaches in Mt. Lebanon.
From June 24, 2013 through April 28, 2014 the Commission has had the turf project on its discussion session agenda seven times either as a stand alone item or as part of SAB presentations. On November 25, 2013, the Commission approved the MWC turf project and Municipality's $750,000 financial commitment. As part of the motion, the Commission formed a turf task force and provided specific direction for them to flesh out the details of the project, including design, engineering and non-municipal share fund raising. The turf project concept has been presented to the Planning Board on April 22, 2014 and to property owners near MWC on April 24, 2014.
In conclusion, the turf project has been discussion in public meetings numerous times over the last two years, and it has been part of the municipality's plans for field enhancements for the last six years.
Thank you for contacting me with your opinion regarding this project. I appreciate your concerns. While we view the project differently, I hope this information is useful.
Sent from my iPhone
Here is an exchange that showed up in my mailbox. Please read what Commissioner Bendel has to say to one of his constituents.
On May 12, 2014, at 6:17 AM, XXXXXXXXX wrote:
Mr. Bendel,
I've learned of the plan to remove natural grass and install artificial turf on the fields on Cedar Blvd. I think this is ill advised, especially when there are so many miles of our roads that are barely passable. There are substantial health and environmental issues, and the plan has the appearance of being rushed through without community discussion.
This is a substantial, permanent financial burden to put on our static, if not declining, tax base. I urge you to oppose this idea.
From: John Bendel <jbendel@mtlebanon.org>
Sent: Mon, May 12, 2014 9:10 am
Subject: Re: artificial turf
Thank you for contacting me about the turf project.
The turf project approved for Middle/Wildcat field (MWC) field in Mt. Lebanon is the culmination of many years of discussion, analysis and research to address the shortage of field space. Addressing the shortage of fields has been a long-standing priority for our community, and over the last decade there have been multiple attempts to expand the number fields and/or increase the use (the number of games/practices) on existing fields. However, until the MWC project, no significant enhancements have been implemented to address this priority.
Most fields in Mt. Lebanon are diamond-based, which are designed primarily for baseball and softball. Over the last decade or so, the popularity of the sports using rectangular-based fields such as lacrosse, soccer and field hockey has increased significantly. Therefore, the focus of field enhancements has been to expand the number of rectangular-based fields.
Information on the approved turf project - description, concept plan and a variety of presentations, can be found on the Municipal website at:
http://mtlebanon.org/index.aspx?NID=2199
I support the project because it:
- Increases field slots available by 60%; turf will withstand continuous use
- Benefits many residents - there were 3,600 total registrations in field-based youth sports programs in 2013, plus many more residents involved on School District sports teams
- Is supported by all field sports associations
- Includes non-municipal contributions of $250,000 toward the $1 million initial capital cost, and requires a use fee that will pay for a portion of the field replacement cost
- Involves a partnership with the School District whereby the District will maintain the field (reducing maintenance cost to the Municipality by almost $14,000 annually compared to the current maintenance cost. The estimated annual maintenance cost for the School District is $7,000, a net saving to the tax payers of $7,000 per year); and in return the District’s sports teams will have use of the field
- Leverages existing access, parking, restrooms, concessions and lights at MWC
With respect the health and safety issues relative to a new turf field, Mt. Lebanon is able to draw upon about 40 years of direct experience. Turf was first installed in Mt. Lebanon in the 1970s. In fact, over that period, we have the experience of a variety of different and improved turf products as they have evolved over the years. Therefore, as the Municipality has evaluated turf generally, as well as the specific turf products currently under consideration for Middle and Wildcat, we have relied upon the following criteria: (1) specific experiences in Mt. Lebanon, (2) independent testing under conditions that are similar to those present in Mt. Lebanon, (3) information provided by governmental agencies (Department of Environmental Protection, etc.), and (4) other information that is widely accepted as independent and credible.
Field enhancements and this project have been discussed in public meetings, included in long-range and short-range plans for many years. I have prepared the follow summary to put the long history of this project in perspective.
My historical knowledge doesn't go back as far as others, but I know that the land purchases at McNeilly and Twin Hills were intended, at least in part, to expand our athletic fields. For a variety of reasons, primarily cost related, the fields were never developed at these locations.
The Municipality's priority for field enhancements is well documented. The Municipality's annual Capital Improvements Plan (CIP), which is our five-year plan for identifying priority projects, has included field development for many years. In fact, the turf project has been included in the last six CIPs beginning in 2009. The CIP is recommended annually by the Planning Board and approved by the Commission, and is discussed at several meetings each year at the Planning Board and Commission. All of these meetings are open to the public and the Commission meetings are video recorded.
In addition, the recently adopted 2013 Comprehensive Plan (Plan), which is our community's planning and development guide for the next 10 years, specifically includes the turf project as a priority. The Plan development included significant opportunity for resident and stakeholder participation. A core planning team made up of a cross-section of representatives of boards and authorities led the process, and a variety of sub-teams focused on specific issues. The opportunity for public input was provided multiple times via a variety of means throughout the 18 month long planning process. The Plan was recommended by the Planning Board and approved by the Commission in 2013.
More recently, in 2012-14, the Commission established recreation and field improvements as a high priority during its annual goal setting retreats. As a result, the Commission has made significant capital investments in recreation facilities in recent years - pool improvements, tennis center (lighting at two courts, concrete stairs and sidewalks and renovations at the tennis center building), several neighborhood park projects, upgrades to the recreation center and ice rink and new equipment (lawn mower at golf course and electric Zamboni). Additional recreation enhancements at Robb Hollow and Northmeadowcroft Park are in the planning phase. Despite this cumulative multi-million dollar investment in recreation, the Municipality has done little to address the long-standing priority for field enhancements.
Since 2012, several field enhancement alternatives have been evaluated by the Commission. The assessment of field options was completed parallel with the development of the Comprehensive Plan as was the case for several other community priorities. If fact, several goals in the Plan are already complete and many more are in the development and planning stages. The Commission began addressing the lack of field space by assessing the opportunities to increase use of its existing fields. Options such as resting fields to improve conditions and better drainage were considered. The Commission did invest in better drainage at Bird field in 2012. With the high demand for field space, the ability to rest fields was not considered a viable option.
The Commission next looked at creating new field space, which is difficult in a highly developed community like Mt. Lebanon. On March 13, 2012, with the assistance of Gateway Engineering, at a discussion session, the Commission reviewed the alternatives listed below. Gateway's presentation can be found at http://mtlebanon.org/DocumentCenter/Home/View/2660
- McNeilly - $3-4 million, multi-field development
- Robb Hollow - Three fields, one on the upper section and two near the Public Works area along Cedar
- Twin Hills - one field
- Brafferton - drainage improvements and conversion from a diamond-based baseball field to rectangle field
- Turfing of MWC and Mellon
The field enhancement alternatives presented in March 2012, were the subject of discussion at various times throughout 2012 and 2013. The projects at McNeilly and Twin Hills were not supported by the Commission and were not pursued. The McNeilly project was not considered viable for several reasons, including the $3-4 million cost and the distance from most areas of the Municipality. The proposed field at Twin Hills was not considered due to its relatively small size, access issues and other development constraints.
The Municipality continued its evaluation of the Robb Hollow, Brafferton and turf options.
Robb Hollow - after additional discussion, the upper field at Robb Hollow was considered the best option at that location. The project in the upper section of Robb Hollow included a full-sized field and unlike the proposed fields along Cedar, it did not encroach on the area used by Public Works. This project was discussed multiple times in 2012, including October 9 and 22. The Municipality completed additional engineering work on the proposed upper field. In late-2012 the Commission decided not to pursue the upper field development due to the rising cost estimate of at least $1.3 million, which included field development, access, parking and transfer of leaf processing to a new location. It was estimated that the transfer of the leaf processing would add approximately $30,000 annually to annual operating expenses. The project would have resulted in the loss of nearly 7 acres of trees, created steep slopes due to excavation and was to be built in close proximity to homes in an adjoining neighborhood.
Brafferton - the Commission approved $197,400 for improvements to Brafferton in 2012. The proposal was to make drainage improvements, remove the baseball diamond and convert the surface to a rectangular field. The Commission reviewed this project multiple times during discussion sessions in 2012 and 2013. The project recognized the need to add an access road and parking to accommodate this new configuration. The access road and parking were estimated to cost an additional $133,000. The newly formed Sports Advisory Board (SAB) and the Commission supported this project. On September 17, 2013 the Brafferton bidding process resulted in one bidder submitting a bid of $845,000 for a large field plus parking and access road (alternate 2A). The Commission rejected this bid due to the high cost and has not pursued this project since that time.
Turf - as noted above, the turf project has been in the Municipality's CIP every year since 2009. The engineer's opinion of probable cost has roughly been around $1 million for the turfing of either Mellon or MWC. The sports community has supported a turf project for many years. On June 25, 2012, the Youth Sports Alliance (YSA), which at the time represented all field based sports in Mt. Lebanon, presented a proposal to turf and add lighting to MWC at a public meeting. On July 10, 2012 the Commission had a follow-up discussion on the YSA proposal. On July 23, 2012 a presentation opposing the turf project was made to the Commission.
A series of Commission discussion sessions on August 27, September 11, September 24, 2012, included the use of the Municipality’s unassigned fund balance for capital projects. Field enhancements were part of these discussions.
On November 26, 2012, the Commission unanimously voted to form the SAB (refer to the purpose statement below). The creation of the SAB provided an opportunity to have a board focused on enhancing the recreational facilities and services in Mt. Lebanon. Boards and authorities exist 1) To discuss/assess specific issues in greater detail than is possible at Commission meetings, and 2) To make recommendations to the Commission on issues important to the community. The SAB's members were appointed by the Commission in early 2013.
Since its first meeting in March 2013 through April 2014, the SAB has discussed field improvements at seven meetings, in particular the Brafferton and turf projects. On June 6, 2013, the SAB voted to recommend a turf project to the Commission as its highest priority. At the SAB's October 3 and November 7, 2013 meetings the SAB voted to recommend the MWC turf project for the Commission's approval. The SAB's recommendations to support the turf project were presented to the Commission on June 24, November 12 and November 25, 2013. All of the SAB meetings are open to the public and are video recorded.
SAB's Purpose
- Review and assess all sports-related facilities and services in Mt. Lebanon.
- Recommend possible changes and improvements to sports-related facilities and services.
- Assist in the continued safe provision of athletic opportunities to Mt. Lebanon residents.
- Receive and consider public comment and other public input regarding sports facilities and services.
- Support, promote and/or provide programs and services to assist athletes and coaches in Mt. Lebanon.
From June 24, 2013 through April 28, 2014 the Commission has had the turf project on its discussion session agenda seven times either as a stand alone item or as part of SAB presentations. On November 25, 2013, the Commission approved the MWC turf project and Municipality's $750,000 financial commitment. As part of the motion, the Commission formed a turf task force and provided specific direction for them to flesh out the details of the project, including design, engineering and non-municipal share fund raising. The turf project concept has been presented to the Planning Board on April 22, 2014 and to property owners near MWC on April 24, 2014.
In conclusion, the turf project has been discussion in public meetings numerous times over the last two years, and it has been part of the municipality's plans for field enhancements for the last six years.
Thank you for contacting me with your opinion regarding this project. I appreciate your concerns. While we view the project differently, I hope this information is useful.
Sent from my iPhone
Saturday, May 3, 2014
Bridge sinking three inches?
Any truth to the rumor that the new bridge at the high school has sunk three inches? Or that the gym has sunk? I just heard that this morning. Truth be told, I have not listened or watched any construction updates, so please forgive me if this is old news or inaccurate information.
While I am on the subject of our high school crown jewel, a Lebo Citizens reader has sent me photos of our artificial turf that was installed at the high school in 2010. For those of you who have not been up there, it looks like a rat's nest.
The blades of "grass" are flat and matted. Rubber tire infill is all over the track. It is worn along edges of the field where use is limited. Seams are coming apart. The school district is to maintain the new toxic turf at Middle and Wildcat Fields, or that is what the Mt. Lebanon High School Athletic Director has committed to. Where is School Board Director Ed Kubit? He is the school district liaison on the Sports Advisory Board. He has been missing in action at the SAB meetings. Why hasn't he presented any information to his peers on the school board about this alleged field maintenance agreement? We just know about general discussions between the two Roycroft royals.
"For The Board" Cappucci wrote to a constituent about these photos. Here is her response.
Obviously I am not a sports jock, but how much activity occurs on the edges of the field? The worn and matted appearance is consistently bad everywhere on the field.
Even the curbs near the high school stadium are a disaster. Can't Mt. Lebanon maintain anything properly?
.JPG)
Please sign this petition if you want to halt public funds for use of artificial turf at Wildcat and Middle Fields.
While I am on the subject of our high school crown jewel, a Lebo Citizens reader has sent me photos of our artificial turf that was installed at the high school in 2010. For those of you who have not been up there, it looks like a rat's nest.
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
.JPG) |
| Installed July 2010 |
The blades of "grass" are flat and matted. Rubber tire infill is all over the track. It is worn along edges of the field where use is limited. Seams are coming apart. The school district is to maintain the new toxic turf at Middle and Wildcat Fields, or that is what the Mt. Lebanon High School Athletic Director has committed to. Where is School Board Director Ed Kubit? He is the school district liaison on the Sports Advisory Board. He has been missing in action at the SAB meetings. Why hasn't he presented any information to his peers on the school board about this alleged field maintenance agreement? We just know about general discussions between the two Roycroft royals.
"For The Board" Cappucci wrote to a constituent about these photos. Here is her response.
From: Elaine Cappucci [mailto:ECappucci@mtlsd.net]
Sent: Friday, May 2, 2014 1:16 PM
Subject: RE: high school turf
The high school turf is properly groomed/maintained regularly (at least once per month). The loft in the turf will vary depending on when it was groomed and how much activity has occurred on the turf.
Elaine Cappucci
Obviously I am not a sports jock, but how much activity occurs on the edges of the field? The worn and matted appearance is consistently bad everywhere on the field.
Even the curbs near the high school stadium are a disaster. Can't Mt. Lebanon maintain anything properly?
For a $1 million+, let's remove this:
 |
| Installed ???? |
So that we can have this:
 |
| Installed July 2010 |
Saturday, April 12, 2014
Let's hear from the men too!
Lebo Citizens reader and frequent commenter, Charlotte Stephenson spoke about the problems associated with artificial turf at a recent ESB meeting. With her permission, I have published Charlotte's letter below.
Dear Fellow Concerned Mt. Lebanon Residents:
The video of the April 10 Environmental Sustainability Board meeting is now available to watch on the www.mtlebanon.org website.
There are many reasons why this project is not good for our community and they range from the threat to public health to wasteful economic policy and improper ethical political procedures [Kristen Linfante told a bold faced lie when she stated the ESB was behind the project] in play where certain Commissioners are supporting pet projects in spite of the common good. Did you know that our municipal employee is fundraising for a local non-profit agency to secure funding for this project? Yes, your tax dollars are at work there.
Please send this to friends or neighbors who are not aware of what is in the works for us. Working together, perhaps we can change the course on this problem situation in our community.
Thank You,
Charlotte StephensonJust as James Cannon III came forward with his Keeping It Real presentation, I hope more men get involved and express their concerns with toxic turf. It appears to me that the SAB, Commission, and Municipal staff seem to be more receptive to men. Come on, Dads. We need your help.
Sunday, April 6, 2014
Toxic Newcomers Turf will cost more
The Crown Jewel Toxic Turf Project being built to lure unsuspecting newcomers to the community and will allegedly increase the value of each and every one of our homes is going to cost taxpayers more than expected. According to the Sports Advisory Board - April 3, 2014 video, the Middle/Wildcat Toxic Turf Project will be 1,000 square feet more than initially thought. A better survey was done and indicates the true size will be 111,200 square feet. The soccer field will be 165x320, not 180x360. The area will be smaller than the High School and Jefferson fields. All soccer games and varsity games will use 2 time slots. The fields will not be available for simultaneous use. I would love to have a revised time slot number using that information.
At the beginning of the meeting, a very powerful message was delivered in citizens comments by a former Mt. Lebanon Soccer/Basketball mom. She started out by saying that there is a definite need for more fields in Mt. Lebanon. Turfing an existing field with toxic turf does not solve any problems. I guess this woman is a research scientist and analyzed the existing data out there concerning the toxicity of artificially turfed fields, both organic infill and synthetic infill, as well as the blades of grass and backing. Her conclusions were that artificial turf was marketed and studied for adult, professional use only. Many other factors were not considered, including the size and metabolism of children, which she identified in her comments. She spoke for about 20 minutes and there were 10 minutes of Q and A's.
The day after the SAB meeting, on April 4, 2014, a comment was posted on Four more documents from the mother of all RTKs at 1:29 PM, which I found very disturbing.
OK, back to the meeting. Core samples were done and indicate no rock. Plans include a portable pitchers mound on Middle and a permanent clay mound for Wildcat. David Donnellan promised to get the concept plan of the layout online within a couple of days of the Sports Advisory Board meeting. Tuesday's Discussion Session Agenda reveals that this will be discussed.
The good news is that The Mt. Lebanon Community Endowment website, Field Improvement Project Fund is up and running. Dave Franklin sent 200-300 emails during its roll out and raised $2500 in 48 hours. That comes to an average of $7.58 per signature from his petition. The amount raised so far is around $115,000 to $120,000. Field hockey contributed $500 which will give them a small spot to play, under the trees - all said in jest. No mention of the amount of the soccer donation, which John Bendel was uncomfortable sharing with me.
Under Potential Capital Projects, a couple of ideas came up. One was an indoor multipurpose athletic facility. Dave Franklin shared his wife's plan. She said that an elementary school can be closed, move the administrative offices from the high school, and use the fields, auditorium, etc., as a community center.
Finally, a public meeting is planned for all affected neighbors on April 24, 2014 at 6:00 PM. The meeting will be at Middle and Wildcat Fields.
At the beginning of the meeting, a very powerful message was delivered in citizens comments by a former Mt. Lebanon Soccer/Basketball mom. She started out by saying that there is a definite need for more fields in Mt. Lebanon. Turfing an existing field with toxic turf does not solve any problems. I guess this woman is a research scientist and analyzed the existing data out there concerning the toxicity of artificially turfed fields, both organic infill and synthetic infill, as well as the blades of grass and backing. Her conclusions were that artificial turf was marketed and studied for adult, professional use only. Many other factors were not considered, including the size and metabolism of children, which she identified in her comments. She spoke for about 20 minutes and there were 10 minutes of Q and A's.
The day after the SAB meeting, on April 4, 2014, a comment was posted on Four more documents from the mother of all RTKs at 1:29 PM, which I found very disturbing.
Referring to the previous video posted on Lebo Citizens (http://vimeo.com/49518944) regarding the hazards of synthetic turf and featuring two scientists including Kathleen Michels, Ph.D.:
Dr. Michels has been nominated to be the "Mom on a Mission 2014" by HealthyChild, Healthy World.
http://healthychild.org/mom-on-a-mission-finalist/kathleen-michaels/
Some of the mothers in Mt Lebanon who have advocated for healthy playing fields have been threatened, mocked, and intimidated by members of the Sports Advisory Board. One elected mother received such a threatening email from a Mt Lebanon coach that it was turned over to the police.
Ask yourself, Mothers, if artificial turf were good for Mt Lebanon, why would Dr. Michels be nominated for this honor by Healthy Child, Healthy World, and at the very same time, why would mothers who feel the same way in Mt Lebanon be treated with such aggression, hostility, disparagement, and unfairness?
OK, back to the meeting. Core samples were done and indicate no rock. Plans include a portable pitchers mound on Middle and a permanent clay mound for Wildcat. David Donnellan promised to get the concept plan of the layout online within a couple of days of the Sports Advisory Board meeting. Tuesday's Discussion Session Agenda reveals that this will be discussed.
The good news is that The Mt. Lebanon Community Endowment website, Field Improvement Project Fund is up and running. Dave Franklin sent 200-300 emails during its roll out and raised $2500 in 48 hours. That comes to an average of $7.58 per signature from his petition. The amount raised so far is around $115,000 to $120,000. Field hockey contributed $500 which will give them a small spot to play, under the trees - all said in jest. No mention of the amount of the soccer donation, which John Bendel was uncomfortable sharing with me.
Under Potential Capital Projects, a couple of ideas came up. One was an indoor multipurpose athletic facility. Dave Franklin shared his wife's plan. She said that an elementary school can be closed, move the administrative offices from the high school, and use the fields, auditorium, etc., as a community center.
Finally, a public meeting is planned for all affected neighbors on April 24, 2014 at 6:00 PM. The meeting will be at Middle and Wildcat Fields.
Saturday, March 22, 2014
Spreading the word
While some of our commissioners and Sports Advisory Board members are working hard to raise non-municipal dollars to fund the Middle/Wildcat Turf Project, I hope this message is also delivered to the field sports groups. Parents, you need to spread the word.
Tuesday, March 4, 2014
Mother of all RTKs continued UPDATED 2X
I went through the Right To Know and pull out what I thought was important for this post. SAB highlights
- Page 9 Dave Franklin sent an email to Kristen and John about Kelly's engagement of the Parks Advisory Board. Keep in mind, Dave Franklin is the PAB representative on the Sports Advisory Board.
- Page 11 Tim White to present program to Lacrosse on January 15, 2014
- Page 13 Concerns from a Parks Advisory Board member on January 12, 2014
- Page 23 and 28 refer to Astroturf's warranty and owner's manual. Neither were included in my RTK.
- Page 34 Geoturf mentions financing options
- Page 36-37 Discussion concerning the resident representing himself to Geoturf as a consultant to the Commission
- Page 39 The third and final email from Dave Brumfield.
Much more to come. This sure is a slow process.
Update March 5, 2014 8:12 AM Kristen Kelly RH exchange
Update March 5, 2014 9:58 AM Here is an email forwarded to Kristen by our municipal planner, Keith McGill concerning Recreation Director David Donnellan's and Municipal Grant Writer, Katherine Heart's efforts for private funding to turf Middle and Wildcat Fields.
Update March 5, 2014 8:12 AM Kristen Kelly RH exchange
Update March 5, 2014 9:58 AM Here is an email forwarded to Kristen by our municipal planner, Keith McGill concerning Recreation Director David Donnellan's and Municipal Grant Writer, Katherine Heart's efforts for private funding to turf Middle and Wildcat Fields.
Wednesday, February 12, 2014
Oh snap SAB! UPDATED
As I mentioned in a previous post, the Sports Advisory Board (SAB) gave their report on the artificial turf project for Middle and Wildcat Fields last night. David Donnellan was kind enough to email a copy of the presentation.
The videos have been uploaded on the municipal website.
The videos have been uploaded on the municipal website.
I thoroughly enjoyed last night's Discussion Session Part 1, specifically when the Environmental Sustainability Board (ESB) made their official statement concerning artificial turf. Since members of the ESB were in the audience, Kelly Fraasch asked if they could hear from the ESB. See 38:57 time stamp. At 39:10, Dave Brumfield declared that they got the ESB's recommendation. At 39:16, you can hear from a member of the ESB say, "No you didn't."
At 40:40, Maria Joseph made an official statement. She started out by saying that the ESB was misrepresented by the Commission liaison. Kristen interrupted Ms. Joseph to say that it wasn't true.
Ms. Joseph included the fact that residents on neighboring streets were never notified of the potential risks. At 46:05, Kristen continued to defend herself.
Dave Franklin stated that the fields will not be irrigated because we don't have enough hot days to warrant irrigation. (Remember how the pool pump went down on 100º days?) He also challenged the ESB saying that they were alerted to this plan. He said that the minutes show that turf has been discussed at the last three or four ESB meetings. Decide for yourself if that is true. ESB minutes
Kelly Fraasch asked why residents in her ward were never notified about turf going on Middle and Wildcat Fields. Dave Brumfield jumped on Kelly saying that they have NEVER notified neighbors about projects. Kelly asked, "What about Brafferton?" Dave said that he only asked them a question. Here is a question for Dave. What about dogs being allowed in Williamsburg? I seem to remember him having a meeting in Williamsburg Park to discuss the subject.
I loved how Kathy Hrabovsky told Dave Brumfield, "Sorry, but you are interrupting." The Daves and Kristen looked REALLY bad. Finally, Kristen said that there were five elected officials here who are responsible for making decisions. Ultimately, it is their decision. It is three Commissioners' decision to turf those fields because they saw no other option. She said that there was simply no place to put grass fields. Uh, what about Robb Hollow? Kelly had plans for TWO FIELDS. What happened to improving Brafferton? Kristen said that they had no choice. She also pointed out that the new commission liaison (Kelly Fraasch) to the ESB happens to be against turf. What is Kristen insinuating?
One other thing that I would like to point out that transpired during the SAB presentation. Dan Deiseroth, municipal engineer from Gateway and also first donor, but now anonymous, had a meeting with the Mt. Lebanon Community Endowment. I couldn't believe it when I heard it. Go to 12:09 of Part 1 of the Discussion Session. That just doesn't feel right to me.
Finally, once again, I want to thank the Mt. Lebanon Environmental Sustainability Board for their official statement.
Update February 15, 2014 11:08 AM Here is the ESB statement that was read at the February 11 Commission discussion meeting.
Update February 15, 2014 11:08 AM Here is the ESB statement that was read at the February 11 Commission discussion meeting.
Monday, January 13, 2014
"Whoa," says the EPA. UPDATED
The EPA has had a change of heart regarding the safety of artificial turf.
I hope people take the time to watch the SAB video. Chip, we all heard what you said about the resident missing from the meeting. Shame on you.
Highlights include: John Bendel connected the SAB to the Mt. Lebanon Community Endowment. This would eliminate the need for the SAB to file for 501(c)(3) status. Donations would go into a separate project fund account, with the details TBD of who has access to it, the SAB or the Municipality.
Donations received so far:
1st official donation came from Gateway Engineering for $4,000 in 2013. There may possibly be more coming in 2014.
$25,000 Baseball Association (which amounts to $29/player) Pledged
$5,000 Football Association (which amounts to $31/player) Pledged
$5,000 may be coming from Softball.
The MLCE fee for this is $1,000, I believe.
Another thing that came out of the meeting is that if the SAB does not meet their target of $250,000, that the donations will be used for field maintenance.
Update January 14, 2014 10:34 PM During the Citizen Comments portion of tonight's commission meeting, I handed out reprints of the EPA website article, The Use of Recycled Tire Materials on Playgrounds & Artificial Turf Fields, in addition to reprints of the letter to the executive director of Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) from the United States Environmental Protection Agency dated December 16, 2013.I asked for organic fill, if the project goes through.
Update April 12, 2014 9:30 PM Knowing what I know now, I retract what I wrote on January 14. Organic infill doesn't make the turf safe. The blades of "grass" and the backing are also toxic. The only safe turf is natural grass.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has “stepped back” from previous safety assurances about artificial turf made from recycled tires, according to a written press release.This quote came from The New Haven Register article, More studies needed on artificial turf fields, EPA says. What concerns me is that if you watch the Sports Advisory Board meeting video from Thursday evening, you will see David Donnellan mention that developing McNeilly is in the Capital Improvements Projects (the CIP, a.k.a. The Wish List). So hazardous artificial turf would be installed on three municipal fields, as well as the artificial turf presently at the high school.
“EPA now admits that it has no idea about the extent of chemical exposure to children and athletes playing on these surfaces,” said Jeff Ruch, executive director of the nonprofit Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility.
I hope people take the time to watch the SAB video. Chip, we all heard what you said about the resident missing from the meeting. Shame on you.
Highlights include: John Bendel connected the SAB to the Mt. Lebanon Community Endowment. This would eliminate the need for the SAB to file for 501(c)(3) status. Donations would go into a separate project fund account, with the details TBD of who has access to it, the SAB or the Municipality.
Donations received so far:
1st official donation came from Gateway Engineering for $4,000 in 2013. There may possibly be more coming in 2014.
$25,000 Baseball Association (which amounts to $29/player) Pledged
$5,000 Football Association (which amounts to $31/player) Pledged
$5,000 may be coming from Softball.
The MLCE fee for this is $1,000, I believe.
Another thing that came out of the meeting is that if the SAB does not meet their target of $250,000, that the donations will be used for field maintenance.
Update January 14, 2014 10:34 PM During the Citizen Comments portion of tonight's commission meeting, I handed out reprints of the EPA website article, The Use of Recycled Tire Materials on Playgrounds & Artificial Turf Fields, in addition to reprints of the letter to the executive director of Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) from the United States Environmental Protection Agency dated December 16, 2013.
Update April 12, 2014 9:30 PM Knowing what I know now, I retract what I wrote on January 14. Organic infill doesn't make the turf safe. The blades of "grass" and the backing are also toxic. The only safe turf is natural grass.
Friday, November 22, 2013
Son of a bitch!
Sorry for my crudeness, but this is bullshit. November 25, 2013 Commission meeting agenda
John Bendel will be introducing this atTuesday Monday night's meeting:
JB 9. Consideration to assign funds for athletic field improvements.
The Commission would like to establish a process for funding field enhancements at Middle/Wildcat field. The project scope and opinion of cost was prepared by the Municipal Engineer and involves the installation of artificial turf covering the entire field surface, including the infields and outfields.
The Commission prefers to install a turf product with organic infill.
The Municipality will establish a team led by the Recreation Director with representation from the School District, Gateway Engineering and representatives from the Sports Advisory Board. The team will:
● Create a strategy for field use and fee structure to cover the annual field use fee
● Develop a strategy for funding the initial nonmunicipal share
● Draft a maintenance agreement with the School District
● Develop a list of turf vendors, including those offering organic infill
● Create an RFP schedule with construction targeted to begin by August 1, 2014
● Present recommendations to the Sports Advisory Board (SAB) and Commission by February 11, 2014
In total, the Commission intends to allocate $750,000 in municipal funds for the turf project, including $637,400 by action at tonight’s meeting. The remaining $112,600 will be considered in a separate motion at a future Commission meeting.
Recommended Action: Move to: (a) Remove the assignment of $137,400 from the Brafferton project and transfer it for field enhancements, and (b) Assign $500,000 from the unassigned fund balance for field enhancements.
John Bendel will be introducing this at
JB 9. Consideration to assign funds for athletic field improvements.
The Commission would like to establish a process for funding field enhancements at Middle/Wildcat field. The project scope and opinion of cost was prepared by the Municipal Engineer and involves the installation of artificial turf covering the entire field surface, including the infields and outfields.
The Commission prefers to install a turf product with organic infill.
The Municipality will establish a team led by the Recreation Director with representation from the School District, Gateway Engineering and representatives from the Sports Advisory Board. The team will:
● Create a strategy for field use and fee structure to cover the annual field use fee
● Develop a strategy for funding the initial nonmunicipal share
● Draft a maintenance agreement with the School District
● Develop a list of turf vendors, including those offering organic infill
● Create an RFP schedule with construction targeted to begin by August 1, 2014
● Present recommendations to the Sports Advisory Board (SAB) and Commission by February 11, 2014
In total, the Commission intends to allocate $750,000 in municipal funds for the turf project, including $637,400 by action at tonight’s meeting. The remaining $112,600 will be considered in a separate motion at a future Commission meeting.
Recommended Action: Move to: (a) Remove the assignment of $137,400 from the Brafferton project and transfer it for field enhancements, and (b) Assign $500,000 from the unassigned fund balance for field enhancements.
Wednesday, October 2, 2013
"Turf Project"
While the readers on Lebo Citizens have taken a beating for not wanting to go with Pay As You Throw, the Sports Advisory Board, a.k.a. Turf Board meeting agenda for tomorrow has been posted here and here:
1. Call to Order and Roll Call
2. Citizen Comments
3. Approval of the June 6, 2013 Meeting Minutes
4. Asset/Inventory Review from Each Organization (Worksheets should be submitted prior to the meeting)
5. Field Sign Sponsorship Program
6. Brafferton Field Project Update
7. Cedar Boulevard Parking Lot Project
8. Turf Project
9. Inventory Field/Athletic Facilities and Utilization
10. Forum for Unrepresented Groups
11. Other Short and Long Term Goals
12. Announcements
a. Historic Preservation Board National Register Designation Meeting- December 5 at 6:00 p.m. Room C, Municipal Building
13. Adjournment
Mt. Lebanon Sports Advisory Board Meeting Agenda
October 3, 2013, 8:00 p.m.
Municipal Building Room 104C
1. Call to Order and Roll Call
2. Citizen Comments
3. Approval of the June 6, 2013 Meeting Minutes
4. Asset/Inventory Review from Each Organization (Worksheets should be submitted prior to the meeting)
5. Field Sign Sponsorship Program
6. Brafferton Field Project Update
7. Cedar Boulevard Parking Lot Project
8. Turf Project
9. Inventory Field/Athletic Facilities and Utilization
10. Forum for Unrepresented Groups
11. Other Short and Long Term Goals
12. Announcements
a. Historic Preservation Board National Register Designation Meeting- December 5 at 6:00 p.m. Room C, Municipal Building
13. Adjournment
I don't understand how we can have a group of people wanting a Pay As You Throw program which encourages us to recycle, and then turn around and ask for artificial turf. At least Brumfield is consistent. He is against the PAYT idea. For that, I have to give him credit.
Anyone up to attending tomorrow's meeting?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)